Restaurant Servers Reveal the Most Insane Things Customers Have Ever Asked Them For

Restaurant servers have met many people during work hours and some have extremely odd requests. Forget asking for extra napkins or a drink refill, these requests are weird and some are downright disgusting. Keep reading to learn what insane things customers have asked servers for.

A bunch of lemons

Lemons on grey wooden surface

Lemons | 5second/iStock/Getty Images

In an odd — but not gross — request, customers ask for lemons. “In New Orleans, surprisingly often, people used to ask for a bunch of lemons and then use the sugar packets on the table to make lemonade with their water in an attempt to not have to pay for an actual lemonade,” a server told Food & Wine.

Hint: Requests don’t much crazier than this.

A customer propositioned their server

Young couple

A server hands out menus. | gpointstudio/iStock/Getty Images

Asking for dessert usually elicits one of two answers — yes or no — but not in this case. Here’s what happened to a server when they offered guests dessert. “Me: Any dessert? Guest: My wife wants you for dessert,” a server told Food & Wine. We don’t know how the server responded but needless to say, the encounter was awkward.

Hint: A customer needed more light. 

A customer asked for a candle

A server takes an order from a couple.

A server takes an order. | Minerva Studio/iStock/Getty Images

“Recently in full daylight, a woman asked me if I had a candle so that she could read the menu,” a server told Food & Wine. We’re still trying to figure a scenario in which this would make sense. Maybe it was a particularly overcast day?

Hint: A customer mixed Coke drinks.

1 person wanted a mixed soft drink

Coka-Cola and Diet Coke

Coke and Diet Coke | vicm/iStock/Getty Images

A customer ordered “a Coke with 75 percent Diet Coke and 25 percent regular Coke,” a server told Food & Wine. At that point, wouldn’t the customer be OK with drinking a regular Diet Coke? Or adding a sugar packet to the Diet Coke?

Hint: Requests don’t get much cheesier than this.

Is the cheese from Switzerland?

Emmental Swiss cheese

Swiss cheese | Sebalos/iStock/Getty Images

While working at a breakfast café, a customer asked a server “if the Swiss cheese in the Florentine omelet was from Switzerland,” according to Food & Wine. After the server replaced the Swiss cheese with cheddar, the customer said “the cheese looked too processed and to bring her a bagel with cream cheese instead.”

Hint: People are particular about ice cubes.

1 ice cube

Ice cubes

Ice | PhonlamaiPhoto/iStock/Getty Images

Some people prefer ice in their drinks. Others don’t. But some people like a particular number of ice cubes. “One person asked for a Sprite with one ice cube, which kept melting on the way to the table,” a server told Food & Wine.

Hint: Where is this fork from?

Is silverware American?

Silverware

Silverware | Hanohiki/iStock/Getty Images

Typically, customers care that they have silverware and that it’s clean. But one customer asked a question about silverware that stumped their server. A customer asked “for an ‘American fork,'” a server told Food & Wine.

Hint: A customer asked for a unique stirrer stick.

A customer wanted a barista to touch his latte

Barista steaming milk for hot cappuccino

A barista at work | CandyBoxImages/iStock/Getty Images

“When I was a barista, a guy asked me to stir his latte with my finger,” a server told Food & Wine. We don’t know what was going through the guy’s mind at the time but maybe he wanted a handmade latte. Get it? Handmade?

Hint: A customer wanted their server fired for a bizarre reason.

A customer wanted their server fired

Greek salad

Greek salad | robynmac/iStock/Getty Images

“A man demanded to speak to a manager and asked to have me fired because I wouldn’t bring him a Greek salad,” a server told Food & Wine. “We didn’t have Greek salad on the menu, or really any of the ingredients to make one.”

Hint: People didn’t understand wood-fired ovens.

People didn’t understand cooking technique, sent food back

Chicken fajita pizza with peppers and garlic dip

Pizza | Bartosz Luczak/iStock/Getty Images

“When I worked at a Neapolitan pizzeria, people would [send] back pizzas, asking that there not be any black specks on the crust,” a server told Food & Wine. “No matter how patiently you explained wood-fired ovens, they couldn’t get past it being ‘burnt.'”

Hint: The strangest egg request ever.

A customer asked for ‘unfertilized eggs’

Fresh chicken and quail eggs on a wooden rustic background

Eggs | iStock.com/VladislavStarozhilov

While taking an order at IHOP, a woman ordered a meal and I ask her how she’d like her eggs,” a server said on Reddit, according to Irish News. “She replies ‘unfertilized.’” Thinking it’s a joke, the server laughed and brushed off her request but soon realized the woman wasn’t kidding. “She said ‘you know when you crack the egg, and you see that little white bit stuck to the yolk? That’s the sperm, and I don’t want it in my eggs.’”

Hint: A customer asked for grease.

Fryer grease became dipping sauce

Deep Fryer

French fries in a fryer | phillyskater/iStock/Getty Images

A customer “asked for a cup of the sauce at the bottom of the plate” after ordering a bloomin’ onion, according to the Irish News. Their server informed them the “sauce” was actually fryer grease. “I don’t care what it is, just get me a cup of it,” the customer replied. The customer proceeded to eat the bloomin’ onion and dip it in fryer grease.

Hint: A new use for hot sauce.

Hot sauce and beer

Beer in glass on wooden surface

Beer in a glass | grafvision/iStock/Getty Images

“I work at a pizza restaurant. This one customer comes in around once a week, and he orders a beer,” a server said, according to the Irish Times. “But he always asks for a side of hot sauce. He takes it and pours it into the beer, mixing it.”

Hint: A new way to serve chicken gravy.

Chicken gravy and Oreo cookies

Oreoes

Oreos | wit88_/iStock/Getty Images

“A few weeks ago someone ordered a cup full of crushed Oreos covered in chicken gravy and that was the exact moment that I lost all faith in humanity,” a Culver’s server said on Reddit, according to the Irish Times.

Hint: Count your french fries.

Customer asked for certain number of fries

Plate with fries potato, ketchup and mayonnaise on the table.

French fries | LIgorko/iStock/Getty Images

At a small town diner, a “guy came in every single day for lunch, and would order a plate of 13 french fries,” a server said on Reddit, according to the Irish Times. “If there were any more or any less, he would politely send it back for us to fix it.”

Check out The Cheat Sheet on Facebook!

Read more: How You Can Get Free Food From These Popular Chain Restaurants

More Articles About:   ,  

More from The Cheat Sheet