‘Bachelor In Paradise’: Fans Are Slamming Caelynn Miller-Keyes on Instagram for Being ‘Dramatic’ Over Blake Horstmann

Hannah Brown may not have found love on her most recent season of The Bachelorette, but now, Bachelor Nation fans are ready to watch rejected hopefuls from seasons past look for love on the beaches of Mexico. Bachelor In Paradise is known for bringing on the drama, and this season, it’s totally delivered already. And contestants Blake Horstmann and Caelynn Miller-Keyes are currently the centers of attention.

Miller-Keyes told cameras during the first episode that she and Horstmann had hooked up prior to their arrival in Paradise. And now, Horstmann has taken to Instagram to share his side of the story. It seems his version of what occurred is causing many to peg Miller-Keyes as a drama queen.

Caelynn Miller-Keyes claimed Blake Horstmann led her on

View this post on Instagram

A ray of sunshine is never wasted ☀️

A post shared by Caelynn Miller-Keyes (@caelynnmillerkeyes) on

It’s no surprise that Bachelor and Bachelorette stars end up getting together every once in a while after production ends, but it seems Miller-Keyes had quite a few scathing claims to make about Horstmann. E! News notes as soon as she arrived on Paradise, she told cameras that she and Horstmann had a fling at Stagecoach back in April. Not only that, but Miller-Keyes also says that Horstmann had sex with Kristina Schulman the night before he was with her. And he also allegedly shared with Miller-Keyes that he had his sights set on Tayshia Adams and Hannah Godwin, too.

Once Miller-Keyes met Chris Harrison at the entrance to Paradise, she spilled how she really feels about potentially seeing Horstmann on the show. And while it was clear that inner turmoil was brewing, she kept her feelings to herself for most of the premiere.

Horstmann shared texts to prove his truth

After fans saw Miller-Keyes’ side of the story while watching Bachelor In Paradise, Horstmann took everything one step further by proving his innocence on Instagram. E! News notes he added personal texts between him and Miller-Keyes to his Instagram story. And the texts show Miller-Keyes reassuring Horstmann that she wanted to exclusively have sex with no strings attached.

Not only did Horstmann release the texts, but he also added a text post to his Instagram to address the situation. Additionally, he posted videos of himself tearfully speaking to the camera to his Instagram story. “Releasing the text messages was the last thing I wanted to do,” he said. “I know that it’s not good but I feel like I have no other choice but to release those, and I hope Caelynn can forgive me one day.”

While the situation is seemingly more dramatic than it needs to be, it seems many are standing by Horstmann following the release of the texts, too. “Speak your truth, no one can take that away from you,” Kristina Schulman commented on his Instagram photo. And Kaitlyn Bristowe also wrote, “Thank you for being vulnerable and honest.”

Fans think Miller-Keyes is dramatizing the whole ordeal

Caelynn Miller-Keyes
Caelynn Miller-Keyes | John Fleenor/ABC via Getty Images

While Bachelor fans may have felt for Miller-Keyes initially, it seems the release of Horstmann’s side of the story has many fans calling her out. On her recent Instagram post showing her talking to Chris Harrison, many have taken to the comments to call her over-dramatic.

“Dont get the drama. I saw ur texts on Blake’s Instagram and he didnt do anything wrong.. u made a mountain out of a molehill.. smh why always drama? [sic],” one fan commented. And another added, “Why are you always the Center of all the drama is the real question [sic].” Yet another commented, “I prefer to hear both sides of the story. Especially since you are known to tell lies on the bachelor. It sounds like he dumped you and now you’re seeking revenge trying to play the poor me card [sic].”

We know Horstmann doesn’t wish any ill will against Miller-Keyes, but it seems the drama’s not over yet now that the texts are out in the open. We’ll have to wait and see if Miller-Keyes has words of her own to share on Instagram regarding the situation.

Check out Showbiz Cheat Sheet on Facebook!