‘Big Brother 21’ Stars Kathryn Dunn and Nick Maccarone Reveal When They Fell in Love With Each Other

Even though Kathryn Dunn and Nick Maccarone were in other “relationships” while they were houseguests in the Big Brother house, they fell for each other in Jury, starting the first-ever “Jurymance.” The couple has continued to date after the show wrapped and recently revealed when they fell in love with each other.

Nick Maccarone Kathryn Dunn
Nick Maccarone | Robert Voets

Kathryn Dunn and Nick Maccarone began dating on ‘Big Brother 21’

In Week 5, Jack Matthews exposed Kathryn Dunn and Holly Allen’s pre-existing relationship, putting a huge target on her back, and she became the second member of the Jury two weeks later.

After losing his alliances, Nick Maccarone positioned himself perfectly between both sides of the Big Brother house. However, Christie Murphy exposed him to save herself. He then ended up on the block the following week, and despite having the ability to choose the other nominee as America’s Prankster, he became the fourth member of the Jury.

Once Maccarone and Dunn were in the Jury house together, they began an unexpected romantic relationship, which the show highlighted. Big Brother fans criticized Maccarone’s actions because he hadn’t officially broken up with Isabella Wang yet.

Dunn has defended her boyfriend, and their relationship, explaining what the show aired did not accurately portray their connection or the bond they formed. In an interview with Your Reality Recaps, she said they have a lot in common, similar sense of humor, and he helped her get through breakdowns she had in the jury house.

Therefore, it’s difficult for her to hear people say negative things about him because she saw a different side of him. Nonetheless, the new couple continued dating after the show wrapped.

Kathryn Dunn and Nick Maccarone continued their relationship

Only a few weeks after the finale, Dunn, Maccarone, and the Six Shooters alliance “raided” Area 51. Then, Dunn took Maccarone to a Dallas Cowboys vs. Philadelphia Eagles football game and a Washington Nationals vs. Houston Astros World Series matchup as they both love sports.

They also attended a “meet and greet” where Dunn allegedly got Maccarone’s face tattooed on her arm. The new couple also visited Bracco in Staten Island, New York, and met Todrick Hall after his performance.

Additionally, Dunn recently started a YouTube channel which features conspiracy videos, and Maccarone has been in two out of four of them.

Kathryn Dunn and Nick Maccarone revealed when they fell in love with each other

In her most recent YouTube video, Dunn and Maccarone guessed how well they knew each other, and every time one of them answered incorrectly, they received a pie in the face.

Even though they both were pied several times, they knew when they fell in love with each other. According to Dunn, she fell in love with Maccarone the first day he came to the Jury house, “looking hot.”

For the next question, the therapist asked Dunn when he fell in love with her. She asked him if he was in love with her, and Maccarone responded, “Yes, I’m 100% in love with you.”

Both of them say they fell in love with each other the first day they saw each other in Jury, even though Dunn hated Maccarone while they were houseguests in the Big Brother house.