‘BiP’: Caelynn Miller-Keyes Says She’d Go Back to Stagecoach Festival

This past season of Bachelor in Paradise was a wild ride for viewers — and a lot of the drama surrounded Blake Horstmann. Horstmann was one of the finalists in Becca Kufrin season of The Bachelorette, and he’s since made a name for himself as one of the biggest flirts in Paradise. And even before he hit the beaches of Mexico, he was getting into trouble at Stagecoach Festival, as he had romantic relations with both Kristina Schulman and Caelynn Miller-Keyes there.

Words, texts, and emotions were exchanged between Miller-Keyes and Horstmann regarding the Stagecoach debacle. But when it comes down to it, Miller-Keyes notes she’d actually go again under certain circumstances. Here’s what she said.

Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Blake Horstmann had major drama at Stagecoach Festival

Blake Horstmann had high hopes for love when he arrived in Paradise, but he was met with some very unhappy ex-lovers. As stated before, Kristina Schulman, who now remains friends with Horstmann, hooked up with him at Stagecoach Festival — and so did Caelynn Miller-Keyes. And Miller-Keyes felt Horstmann ghosted her despite allegedly discussing skipping Paradise with him and pursuing a relationship.

“He ended up sweet-talking me and we spent the night together. And we wake up and I’m in his bed and he’s DMing Hannah G. I’m still in his bed, he’s talking about how hot Tayshia is. I was like, ‘Are you kidding me?’ Like no dude, that’s not OK,” Miller-Keyes said of her experience with Horstmann.

To save his side of the story, Horstmann later released texts from Miller-Keyes showing that she didn’t actually want a serious relationship. While they’ve since hashed things out at the BiP reunion, Miller-Keyes maintained she’d never release his texts when it came down to it.

Kristina Schulman claims even more occurred at Stagecoach that fans didn’t know about

While we know the Miller-Keyes-Schulman-Horstmann love triangle that occurred at Stagecoach, Schulman allegedly had even more to hash out with Miller-Keyes. Schulman spoke to Entertainment Tonight about the festival and claimed Miller-Keyes hooked up with another one of her exes. As Schulman said, “I don’t want to mention who it is, just because it’s not relevant. I just wanted to say what my situation was with Caelynn, and it wasn’t that I just disregarded her from the get-go. It was a little bit more personal and she did it personally.”

According to Cosmopolitan, Schulman addressed the second hookup with Miller-Keyes during the BiP reunion — but it went unaired. Reality Steve also shared what he knew about the situation. “Caelynn doesn’t deny hanging out with him there, and Kristina chimes in that multiple people saw them making out,” the king of reality TV spoilers tweeted.

Miller-Keyes claimed she’d go back

Stagecoach drama brought Miller-Keyes a lot of grief, but she’s now ready to accept it and move on. As she said during an interview with Access, “I internalized a lot in that situation, and so we just had different experiences of what went down.” After that, the interviewer asked Miller-Keyes if she’d ever go to Stagecoach again. She replied, “If Dean wants to go to Stagecoach, let’s go to Stagecoach — I mean, why not? I had a great time last year minus the drama surrounding it.”

We know Miller-Keyes and Dean Unglert are happily together after leaving Paradise together, and it seems her healthy relationship is giving her fresh perspective on the whole situation with Horstmann. All in all, we’re happy to see Miller-Keyes so giddy and in love after everything she went through on the show. And despite being a pageant girl who’s now living in a van with Unglert, it seems their relationship is working perfectly so far!

Check out Showbiz Cheat Sheet on Facebook!