‘BIP’ Think Caelynn Miller-Keyes Is Only Wearing Makeup on One Side of Her Face in Her Instagram Post

Bachelor in Paradise may be over for now, but this past season brought love, heartbreak, and plenty of drama to the small screen. And a lot of it had to do with Caelynn Miller-Keyes. While she had a major bone to pick with Blake Horstmann at first, it was Dean Unglert who arrived on the beach and stole her heart. And though Unglert left Paradise temporarily without her, he returned after realizing how much he liked her. Now, the two are still going strong.

Today, fans are loving seeing what Miller-Keyes and Unglert post about each other on Instagram, as they’re both adventuring to new places near and far in Unglert’s van. And one social media photo of Miller-Keyes’ is getting a lot of attention for other reasons. Fans noticed it looks like she only put makeup on half of her face.

Caelynn Miller-Keyes has a past in pageantry

Caelynn Miller-Keyes attends boohoo x Caelynn Beachside Brunch
Caelynn Miller-Keyes attends boohoo x Caelynn Beachside Brunch | Presley Ann/Getty Images for boohoo.com

Before BIP, Miller-Keyes was on Colton Underwood’s season of The Bachelor. And she made her pageantry history known when she arrived on the scene in her pageant dress and sash. As fans know, this gave her some initial bad blood with Hannah Brown, as she was also in the pageant world and didn’t get along with Miller-Keyes in the past.

Miller-Keyes is now looking to shed her image as the queen of the runway, however. She’s getting in touch with her adventurous side since dating Unglert.

“I’m a pageant girl … but the Miller side of my family … they’re very adventurous, they’re hiking, they live in, like, Airstreams, you know? And so, I’m kind of embracing that side of myself that I never have before, and it’s been great,” she told Access.

Dean Unglert supports Miller-Keyes wearing less makeup

Since she’s lived a glamorous life, Miller-Keyes is used to wearing a ton of makeup — but Unglert made it known he supports her going for a more natural look. During the BIP reunion, fans may have noticed that Miller-Keyes wasn’t nearly as done-up as usual. And that’s because Unglert told her he’d take her on a trip the Maldives if she didn’t wear makeup.

“We have a lot of travel plans coming up. Dean told me if I didn’t wear makeup to the reunion, he’d take me to the Maldives,” Miller-Keyes told Access. “I’d wear, like, a little bit of concealer, blush … I felt very vulnerable, but he challenges me in that way, too.”

While Miller-Keyes may feel slightly exposed without as much on her face, it’s clear fans are loving the look, as many have commented on how much fresher and more beautiful she looks now.

Fans are confused by her Instagram post

Miller-Keyes is up to big things, as she just launched her own clothing collection with boohoo, and she’s an influencer for many other brands that she shares on her Instagram. On Nov. 19, she posted a photo advertising Shein’s Black Friday sale. While some of her followers loved her look, others couldn’t help but notice that something appeared off with her makeup.

“Wait do you have make up on only one side of your face?! I can’t tell haha,” one follower questioned.

Another wrote, “It looks like you forgot to color in an eyebrow!”

And another noted, “Did you only do makeup on one side of your face?”

Miller-Keyes hasn’t made any comments about the potential makeup mishap in the photos, though she is typically quite active in the comments section of her own Instagram. And it doesn’t look like Unglert has commented yet, either, though he’s typically found making snarky comments on her posts, too.

No matter what, we think Miller-Keyes is looking better than ever and are excited to see the adventures she goes on with Unglert next!

Check out Showbiz Cheat Sheet on Facebook!