‘BIP’: Dean Unglert and Caelynn Miller-Keyes Just Won Halloween

Bachelor in Paradise alums, Dean Unglert and Caelynn Miller-Keyes may not have been the most popular couple on the beach this Summer, but the unlikely pair certainly have their fair share of supporters now. Though they are far from the traditional Bachelor couple, their unique relationship seems to be working out well for them. The two have expressed how much they enjoy traveling together and the van life that Unglert has introduced Miller-Keyes to. Now the pair are enjoying celebrating holidays and special occasions with one another. Most recently, they celebrated Halloween together and blew a lot of costumes out of the water.

Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Dean Unglert
Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Dean Unglert | Photo by BG002/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images

Though Miller-Keyes and Unglert will be separated for the official day of Halloween, they still decided to dress up and celebrate the fun holiday together a bit early. Taking to their respective Instagram pages, they both shared images of themselves dressed up as each other. Miller-Keyes dressed up as “Dirtbag Dean” (a nickname that Unglert earned for some of his less than favorable behavior on Bachelor in Paradise) while Unglert dressed as beauty-queen Caelynn, referencing Miller-Keyes’ time spent in the pagent world.

Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Dean Unglert dress as each other for Halloween

“Just a dirtbag and his beauty queen,” Miller Keyes captioned her photos of the pair of them in costume. “We won’t be together for Halloween but we still wanted to scare you so we decided to celebrate early,” Unglert captioned his photos. And while some fans were scared, many were really impressed with the costume ideas and how great both of them looked dressed as one another. “What’s really scary is how nice your legs look,” one fan wrote to Unglert. “This is the best thing I’ve ever seen,” another chimed in. “Still 4 days till Halloween, but I already know this blows every costume post out of the water. #WIN,” another fan of The Bachelor penned.

Sash, jewelry, and heels

One of the best things about the costumes is the level of commitment that both Miller-Keyes and Unglert showed to pull them off. Not only did Unglert shave his infamous mustache, but he also shaved his legs to get into character. Furthermore, he wore a full face of makeup, used makeup to cover up his trademark tattoos, painted his nails, and wore jewelry including earrings and a tiara. To top it all off, Unglert donned heels as well as the Miss Underwood sash that Miller-Keyes wore when she first met former bachelor, Colton Underwood on his season of the show.

Van, mustache, and tattoos

Miller-Keyes, on the other hand, not only replicated Unglert’s exact hat and t-shirt for her costume, but she also donned a fake mustache and bought a toy van to complete the look. Additionally, the former beauty queen allowed Unglert to draw on her with a permanent marker in order to replicate his tattoos. Miller-Keyes made things even funnier when she tagged herself as Unglert and Unglert as herself in the picture that she posted to her Instagram page.

Caelynn Miller Keyes Instagram Screen shot of herself and Dean Unglert
Caelynn Miller Keyes and Dean Unglert

Setting the bar high

We have to agree with the rest of Bachelor Nation that, thus far, these are truly the best costumes to come out of the franchise this year. Both Unglert and Miller-Keyes are no strangers to harsh criticsms, so it’s great to see the pair poke fun at themselves and each other. They might not be the most likely couple, but they certainly seem to be having a ton of fun together. One thing’s for sure, if they’re still together next Halloween, they’ve set the bar pretty high for themselves.