‘Double Shot at Love’ Episode 12: Who Went Home?

DJ Pauly D and Vinny Guadagnino are down to the final five ladies. They invited their Jersey Shore roommates, Ronnie Ortiz-Magro and Jenni “JWoww” Farley to meet the girls. However, JWoww also brought a polygraph technician to give the remaining contestants lie detector tests. Also, the guys take their ladies out on their final dates, and Elle finally makes a decision. Who went home on Double Shot at Love Episode 12?

Double Shot at Love Episode 12
Vinny Guadagnino (L) and DJ Pauly D | Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images

Girls take lie detector tests in ‘Double Shot at Love’ Episode 12

Ronnie and JWoww came to the mansion, with a polygraph technician, to interrogate the girls and see which one is a good fit for Pauly D and Vinny. Elle Wilson was nervous because she didn’t want to reveal which guy she liked more. However, Elle admitted to having feelings for both of them. She also confessed to cheating on an ex-boyfriend.

When JWoww asked Derryn Paige if she would give up her cats for a relationship, Derryn said yes, which turned out to be a lie. She then told the confessional that would choose a boyfriend over her cats, as long as she still got to see her pets every day.

Derryn also admitted to feeling jealous over Nikki Hall and Pauly D’s connection. However, Nikki said she doesn’t feel threatened by Derryn at all. Nikki also raised JWoww’s concerns when she admitted that she was already in love with Pauly D and would marry him tomorrow.

Maria Elizondo was extremely nervous, and her palms were profusely sweating throughout her interrogation. She said she sees herself with Vinny and lied about never having a threesome. Alysse Joyner answered that she would like to date Vinny, but is not in love with him.

Pauly D and Vinny take the girls on final dates in ‘Double Shot at Love’ Episode 12

Vinny took Alysse to a dog adoption place for their final date because he loved how she interacted with his dog. Even though Vinny told Alysse he feels comfortable holding and touching her; she still doesn’t know if their connection is stronger than what he has with Maria.

Pauly and Nikki went bowling because they’re both extremely competitive. Nikki shocked Pauly D when she said he knows her better than anyone else. Pauly D said Nikki is his type, but when he went for his type in the past and it didn’t work out. He also wonders if Nikki would fall out of love with him as quickly as she fell, but Nikki promised that wouldn’t happen.

Vinny and Maria enjoyed a romantic dinner date on a rooftop, but they couldn’t get past each others’ awkwardness. They attempted to kiss a few times; however, their sweatiness and persistent laughing wouldn’t let that happen. Vinny said that he and Maria have so many connections, but they can’t put it together in a relationship. Maria also admitted that she’s an overthinker and paranoid, preventing her from opening up to Vinny.

Pauly also took Derryn on a dinner date and told her she checks several boxes for him. He said her beauty would have caught his eye, but now she’s caught his heart. Derryn told the confessional that she wants to be the only girl for him and is falling in love with him.

Both boys took Elle out because they wanted her to choose between the two of them finally. Vinny and Elle drew portraits of each other, and Vinny told Elle that he thought she was the one since the first day. Pauly enjoyed a Moroccan-themed dinner date with Elle, but they didn’t talk much. Elle became emotional because she realized she wanted Vinny and felt like she’s closing the door on her and Pauly D.

Who went home in ‘Double Shot at Love’ Episode 12?

Pauly and Vinny called all five girls down for the cab ceremony. Elle and Maria were in the bottom two and Vinny, regrettably, had to call a cab for Maria because she still hasn’t opened up. He told Maria she’s one of the most interesting people that he has ever met and Maria admitted in the cab that she got in her own way.

Watch Double Shot at Love Thursdays at 8 P.M. EST on MTV!