‘Double Shot at Love’: Who Do the Girls Like More, Vinny Guadagnino or DJ Pauly D?

When Double Shot at Love began, it seemed like only a few girls were there for Vinny Guadagnino, and the rest wanted to date DJ Pauly D. However, as the season progresses, it looks like more girls are getting closer to Vinny. Who do the girls like more, Vinny or Pauly D?

DJ Pauly D and Vinny Guadagnino Double Shot at Love
Vinny Guadagnino and Paul “DJ Pauly D” DelVecchio | Tom Briglia/FilmMagic

**SPOILER ALERT** This article contains information about the most recent episode of Double Shot of Love (Episode 10) including who the boys eliminated.

Which ‘Double Shot at Love’ girls are there for Vinny Guadagnino?

Alysse Joyner

A fan-favorite from the start because of her calm demeanor and gorgeous freckles, Alysse and Vinny share a strong connection. In Episode 10, they cuddled and kissed, and Vinny told the confessional that he feels comfortable with Alysse. However, she is so quiet that she gets overshadowed by the other girls often.

Brittani “B-Lashes” Schwartz

Vinny noticed B-Lashes was always in the middle of drama happening in the house, but never attempted to talk to either of the bachelors. When he pulled her aside at the rolling skating rink in Episode 8, she told him for the first time that she is more interested in him than Pauly D. At the end of the episode, Vinny decided that she spent too much time with the other girls and not enough time with him, so he called a cab for her that night.

Maria Elizondo

Maria is the most known of the contestants because she recently appeared on MTV’s Are You The One? Season 7. From day one, she and Vinny clicked over weird topics, and they share an intellectual connection unlike anyone else in the house. However, Maria gets jealous and “feels like a moron” when Vinny kisses or hangs out with other girls, as she doesn’t want to get her heart broken on television again. Even though Maria opened up to Pauly D on a group date, she and Vinny are still going strong.

Mish Gao

She didn’t know who Vinny and Pauly D were at the beginning of the season but seemed to like Vinny’s calm nature more. However, she couldn’t handle their Jersey Shore: Family Vacation housemate, Angelina Pivarnick, so Vinny said he didn’t think Mish could handle the spotlight.

Which ‘Double Shot at Love’ girls are there for DJ Pauly D?

Alli Adams

Unfortunately, Alli resembled Pauly D’s ex, singer Aubrey O’Day, too much, so he sent her home the first night.

Derryn Paige

Derryn made an impression on both the bachelors the first night when she crawled on the floor like a cat and slept with a plant that night. They thought she was a little off her rocker, but Pauly D decided to choose her for a one-on-one date. Derryn opened up to him, and he realized she’s also a smart entrepreneur. Derryn has received a few kisses from Pauly D and snuck into his room for a makeup session on Episode 10.

Holly Gurbisz

She came into the house as a huge Pauly D fan, and the boys were turned off by it. Pauly D didn’t like the way she accused him of cheating on Aubrey O’Day and how she always pulled him aside. Ultimately, Pauly D felt like she was living in a fairytale and “like family,” so he sent her home on Episode 9.

Marissa Lucchese

She finally opened up to Pauly D and kissed him in Episode 8. However, it took her too long, and Pauly D’s connections with other girls in the house are stronger. Therefore, he called her cab at the end of Episode 10.

Nadya Erazo

Nadya spent more time with fellow contestant, Suzi, than Pauly D, so he sent her home on Episode 6.

Nikki Hall

On Episode 10, Nikki told Maria, Alysse, and Brittnay that she loved Pauly D. Over the season, Nikki and Pauly D’s relationship has blossomed, much to the dismay of the other girls. The majority of the other contestants do not like Nikki because of her possessive and over-the-top behavior towards Pauly D.

However, Pauly D said he doesn’t see the “craziness” in her the other girls complain about, and he genuinely likes her. Also, Angelina gave Pauly D her stamp of approval for Nikki, saying she’s “crazy but hot.”

Suzi Baidya

When Snooki met the girls, she almost immediately pointed out the resemblance between her and Suzi. Suzi was always down to party, but the guys never saw a more serious side to her and sent her home.

Which ‘Double Shot at Love’ girls are interested in both guys?

Brittnay Dawson

The mother of a 16-year-old initially wanted to date Pauly D. However, after seeing how they both lived, she said wanted to get closer to Vinny. In Episode 10, Snooki liked Brittnay, whom she referred to as “the milf,” the most as a girlfriend for Vinny.

However, she can’t seem to get any alone time with him or Pauly D. By the end of the night; she realized all the girls in the house had kissed one of the bachelors except her. She landed in the bottom two because the guys want to connect with her on a deeper level.

Elle Wilson

Elle initially developed a strong connection with Vinny after he chose her for a one-on-one date on Episode 6. They bonded over their shared love of political science and kissed, which Elle described as “amazing.” However, on Episode 8, she and Pauly D had an in-depth conversation which resulted in a kiss.

After Pauly D told Vinny they kissed, he admitted it hurt his feelings a little bit. On Episode 10, Vinny took Elle with him to get ice because he wanted to see if she still liked him. They ended up kissing in the car; however, Elle said Vinny never told her to stop talking to Pauly D.

Vinny and Pauly D both have two girls who exclusively like them. There are also two girls on the fence, but seem to lean more towards Vinny’s side. Keep watching Double Shot at Love Thursdays at 8 P.M. on MTV!