Fans Are ‘Suspicious’ of Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Dean Unglert’s Relationship After ‘Bachelor in Paradise’

This season of Bachelor in Paradise has already brought the drama, and Caelynn Miller-Keyes seems to be the center of a lot of it. While she was first involved with Blake Horstmann at Stagecoach Festival before Paradise even began, she arrived in Mexico with a broken heart as Horstmann pursued other women. And when she moved on with Dean Unglert, Miller-Keyes thought she was getting another chance at love — but the rug was ripped out from under her in this situation as well.

It seems eagle-eyed fans think Miller-Keyes and Unglert are together now that everything’s said and done, however. But others are suspicious of the rumors of their relationship and have their doubts. Here’s what everyone’s talking about.

Dean Unglert broke Caelynn Miller-Keyes’ heart on Bachelor in Paradise

Dean Unglert has earned himself quite the reputation on reality TV. While he appears nice and genuine at first, his lifestyle of living out of a van and traveling the world with no plans to settle down thwarts any hope of long-lasting romance. And while Caelynn Miller-Keyes knew Unglert was known for breaking hearts, she went against her better judgment and became involved with him anyway. Unfortunately, while he admitted to having real feelings for her, Unglert left the show on her birthday after giving her a rose.

Miller-Keyes was heartbroken, of course, but she remained hopeful when Connor Saeli entered the beach with two other men. Unglert, on the other hand, was then filmed teary-eyed in the van as he went home. But this is far from the end of Unglert and Miller-Keyes’ story, as rumors suggest they’re together now.

There’s evidence to suggest they’re together after the show

Spoilers Ahead!

Heavy reports Reality Steve says Unglert actually returns to Paradise after Miller-Keyes is involved with Saeli. And while Saeli and Miller-Keyes were hitting it off, she goes back to Unglert instead, leaving Saeli completely heartbroken. And it seems there’s plenty of evidence to show Miller-Keyes and Unglert are still involved post-Paradise, too.

According to Refinery29, Unglert and Miller-Keyes had matching Instagram posts from a trip they seemed to have taken together to Spain — though it now appears Miller-Keyes deleted her post. Some even claim you can hear Miller-Keyes laughing in the background of this video of Unglert swimming in a lake. Not only that, but when Unglert posted photos of himself in Venice, Italy, others noted it had to have been Miller-Keyes taking the photos for him.

The publication notes a source also confirmed to E! News that the two took the trip together. “Caelynn traveled to Spain to meet Dean and they were together for four days. They are now in Venice, Italy and plan to travel around Italy together before coming back to LA,” the source claimed.

Others have noticed Unglert doesn’t follow Miller-Keyes on Instagram

Fans seem excited that Miller-Keyes and Unglert really are together now, but many are still suspicious of the relationship news. Miller-Keyes posted this photo of her and Unglert kissing on the beach — and Unglert even added his own comment to it. He wrote, “went from a DM slide to making out with a mustache on a beach in mexico. you go sis.” Oddly enough, one fan seemed to notice Unglert doesn’t follow Miller-Keyes on Instagram. As one fan commented, “he calls her sis in the comments and isn’t following her. I’m suspicious.” And many others seemed to also think Unglert’s comment indicates they aren’t actually in a relationship after all.

Another fan pointed out that none of the participants in Paradise are following each other, however, so perhaps it’s just protocol with the show. And Unglert could just be trying to be sly on social media to surprise viewers with what’s to come. There seems to be more evidence that the two are together than not, so we’re hoping they were able to work things out despite the initial heartbreak.

Check out Showbiz Cheat Sheet on Facebook!