ABC had plenty of options to choose from for the next leading man of The Bachelor. Many men in the series have become fan-favorites and expressed interest in the role, which may have made picking the next Bachelor a tough choice. According to Us Weekly, however, the leading man has been chosen.

Though we don’t know who is set to star as the next Bachelor, we do know it’s been narrowed down to one out of three of Becca Kufrin’s exes from her season of The Bachelorette. Here’s Kufrin’s pick for the next Bachelor, as well as the other two men who could be starring in the next season.

Becca Kufrin’s choice: Jason Tartick

Like many fans of The Bachelor, Kufrin is hoping to see her ex, Jason Tartick, as the next star. “He’s such a sweetheart,” she spilled to E! News. “I want all of those guys to find somebody like what I found in Garrett, but Jason will always have a soft spot in my heart.”

Not only does Kufrin want Tartick to find love, but she thinks he’d be a refreshingly honest and entertaining leading man with his “exuberant personality.” She added, “He’d go all in on every single date and make every girl feel comfortable,” also noting, “[it would be] such a fun season to watch.”

Tartick doesn’t just have the support of Kufrin for becoming the next Bachelor. Another alum from the show, Ashley Iaconetti, has voiced just how much she wants to see him as the leading man. She asked on Instagram, “Where is the petition to make Jason the next Bachelor?”

If Tartick was asked to become the Bachelor, we’re pretty sure he’d have accepted. After all, in an interview with Iaconetti, he claimed he’d “highly consider” taking the job. He’s become a fan-favorite on social media, so people would not be disappointed with this choice.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BkyCoaih9Lf/?taken-by=bkoof

Blake Horstmann is one of the top choices

Another one of Kufrin’s exes ABC had narrowed it down to? Blake Horstmann. As the runner-up from her season, fans fell in love with his raw and honest emotion. He had a truly heartbreaking exit from the show, so it would be super satisfying to see Horstmann get another chance at love.

If Horstmann was chosen, we hope he’ll be ready to get back into the game. After all, he did admit to People, “It was a big blindside [to be sent home]. I truly thought that if it came down to me proposing, that she wouldn’t say no. I thought what we had was real.”

We’re sure the next round of contestants wouldn’t be disappointed with Horstmann as the Bachelor, considering his adorable, quirky attitude and genuine personality.

Colton Underwood could be the next Bachelor

A more controversial choice, Colton Underwood is one of the three men ABC may have chosen. Sure, he is undeniably handsome and has been involved with some humbling charity work, but his time on the show has been up and down.

As one of the few members of Bachelor Nation who is openly a virgin, he certainly has redeeming qualities. But as his time on Bachelor in Paradise has revealed, he hasn’t seemed completely confident in knowing what he wants.

He has, however, admitted that he would “love” to be the next Bachelor. He told Us Weekly, “I know that this show can work. I’ve seen it with Garrett [Yrigoyen] and Becca. I know what it did for me as a person and how it helped me grow into the man I am today. I would love the opportunity if I’m single after Paradise.”