Marvel Fans Don’t Want the X-Men in the MCU: Here’s Why

Following the Fox/Disney merger, the MCU gained access to a slew of comic book characters previously off-limits. With the Fantastic Four and the X-Men now accessible, and waiting to join the soiree of supers that have come to define the Avengers, Kevin Feige (with help from his ingenious team) must find a smooth way to incorporate several mutants and super-powered beings previously inexistent in the specific filmic universe. 

Spider-Man and X-Men Comics
Spider-Man and X-Men Marvel comic books are seen at St. Mark’s Comics August 31, 2009, in New York City | Mario Tama/Getty Images

Many fans are excited to see how, if, and when the MCU will incorporate characters like Storm, Cyclops, Jean Grey, Wolverine, Mr. Fantastic, etc. Will the same actors reprise their coveted roles, or will the creators start from scratch? Will Feige try to recruit Jackman for Logan, as recent reports have indicated? 

Casting and narrative information remains largely unknown — as pure speculation continues to drive the conversation — yet many Marvel fans, despite the allure of seeing the X-Men and the Avengers fight on-screen together, do not want to see the X-Men join the party. But, why? 

Fans see a problem with the X-Men joining the Avengers in the MCU 

In an online discussion concerning the great appeal — and revenue validation — akin to adding the X-Men to the MCU, fans explained why such a move would prove difficult concerning the landscape’s narrative history. The fan stated:

…People don’t want the X-Men because it makes little sense in universe. Where have mutants been? If you make it a new phenomenon you erase the various characters’ entire history. On top of that it never even made sense in the comics why the public loved the other superheroes but not mutants. Why would they not just assume Spider-Man is a mutant? I think they can make it work but that’s why people were against it.”

Reddit User 

When it comes down to it, the Avengers have been fighting the baddies for so long now (since Tony Stark’s appearance in 2008’s Iron Man) that the complete absence of mutants up to this point makes little sense.

Following years of radio silence on the matter with some sudden (and likely cheaply explained) appearance would feel forced. No matter how the writers choose to spin it, we would have a bit of a non-sequitur on our hands.  One marvel enthusiast then chimed in with the following reasons for maintaining separation: 

I’d be totally ok with the X-Men not being part of the MCU, for a few reasons.

1. I think their story works better in its own universe.

2. Their corner of the world is large enough to support a whole shared universe by itself.

3. I don’t want X-Men taking up spots on the schedule that could be given to characters who have never gotten movies before.

4. Why we haven’t heard mutants discussed before will be tough to explain. Not impossible, but tough.

Reddit User

Seeing the X-Men and the Avengers fight alongside each other would prove entertaining. However, many agree that the universes will continue to strive if foraying further into the two distinct worlds rather than combining them into one, which would reduce the number of stories granted to each universe (especially lesser-known characters).