‘The Bachelorette’: Cassie Randolph and Colton Underwood Think Peter The Pilot Should Be The Next Bachelor

Colton Underwood and Cassie Randolph are loving Hannah Brown’s season of The Bachelorette so far. As soon as Hannah was announced to be the next Bachelorette, the couple didn’t have any doubts (even though they might have been in the minority). They both knew if she was exactly herself, it’d be a successful season. So far, Hannah’s been nothing but her truest Alabama Hannah self, and it’s been a pretty good season as a result. 

Recently, Colton and Cassie were asked by ET who they think should be the next Bachelor. Colton, especially, knows what it takes to fill Bachelor shoes. Their decision was unanimous: Peter the Pilot. 

Peter The Pilot and Hannah Brown | John Fleenor via Getty Images
Peter The Pilot and Hannah Brown | John Fleenor via Getty Images

Why Cassie Randolph and Colton Underwood think Peter the Pilot would make a great Bachelor

“I think Peter is super cute. I think he would be a good Bachelor,” said Cassie

“I got my eyes on you, Peter. Let’s go with Peter because Cass thinks he’s really cute, so let’s get him off the market. […] I think Peter has to work on his moves. Did you see him try to pick [Hannah] up for that pool table thing? That wasn’t that smooth, but he can get there,” replied Colton, a little defensively. 

Colton was referring to the moment Peter attempted to pick Hannah up and lay her down on a pool table for a steamy makeout sesh. A great instinct, but his takeoff was a little turbulent. 

As of last night’s episode, it’s clear that Peter’s been working on his moves, though. His time with Hannah in the sauna was extra hot. 

If Peter were to be named the next Bachelor, he’d be the second pilot to star in the role. Former Bachelor Jake Pavelka was also a pilot. But he would be the first Peter, since Peter Kraus turned down the opportunity after Rachel Lindsay’s season of The Bachelorette

Cassie and Colton are not alone in thinking Peter would make a great Bachelor. Fans think he’d be “super cute” in the role as well. 

“PETER IS BACHELOR MATERIAL. THIS MAN HAS THE WHOLE PACKAGE,” tweeted one fan emphatically. 

“Peter is the next bachelor I’m calling it now #ifpeteris31im31,” tweeted another. 

“I swear if Peter becomes the next bachelor, I’m signing up for the #bachelor so quick!” tweeted another enthusiastic fan.  

Cassie Randolph and Colton Underwood reveal their top picks for Hannah Brown 

View this post on Instagram

‘Twas a day I’ll always remember

A post shared by Tyler Cameron (@tylerjcameron3) on

Cassie and Colton were also asked about who their top picks are for Hannah. 

“I honestly think there’s a group of four or five really solid dudes that are, like, good for her. I like her dynamic with Jed, I like her dynamic with Tyler, too,” replied Colton. He’s not alone in his opinion. Bachelorette fans really like Tyler for Hannah. And they used to like Jed before the whole girlfriend scandal unfolded.

We’ll have to wait and see if Colton and Cassie are on-the-money with their picks for Hannah. One thing’s for certain: Luke P. didn’t make the list.     

Read more:‘The Bachelorette’: Hannah B. Says She Understands Now Why Colton Made The Choices He Did