‘A Million Little Things’ Maggie’s Stalker: Every Reddit Fan Theory So Far

After watching A Million Little Things Season 4, many fans turn to Reddit for theories about Maggie Bloom’s (Allison Miller) stalker. Sometimes fans shockingly guess what will happen next in the scripted ABC series, but other times they are way off. Here’s a rundown of every Reddit fan theory, including the most obvious one regarding Maggie’s stalker and which are the most plausible. 

'A Million Little Things' Andrea Bang, Allison Miller, and Danny Wattley talking as Claudi, Maggie and a new bodyguard
‘A Million Little Things’ Andrea Bang, Allison Miller, and Danny Wattley | ABC/Darko Sikman

Is Jon Dixon Maggie’s stalker in ‘A Million Little Things’?

A Million Little Things Season 1 opened with the death of Jon Dixon (Ron Livingston). Gary Mendez (James Roday Rodriguez) brought Maggie to his best friend’s funeral and wake. She hit it off with Delilah (Stephanie Szostak) and Regina (Christina Moses). However, she never met Jon. With the addition of the six-month time jump in A Million Little Things Season 4 Episode 6, the current timeline is about three years after Jon’s death. So, one viewer believes Jon could be the person Maggie thought of in the Nov. 17 episode

“Is Maggie’s stalker Jon because she did mention he died three years ago?” one viewer wrote on Reddit

Another viewer added that Ashley Morales (Christina Ochoa) could be sending the letters from Jon to Maggie. However, the storyline with Jon’s assistant, Ashley, wrapped up in season 1. This fan theory seems the most unlikely since Maggie moved to Boston right around the same time that Jon died by suicide. The two never met, and he wasn’t her former client.

Is Peter Benoit stalking Maggie?

Another Reddit fan theory about Maggie’s stalker in A Million Little Things is that Peter Benoit (Andrew Leeds) sends the letters. 

“I feel like the obvious person is Peter,” one Redditor wrote. “[He] has a thing about Gary and was really against the podcast. Most people watching feel like he just disappeared.”

This fan theory doesn’t seem likely since Sophie Dixon (Lizzy Greene) took her podcast down. Gary and Peter came to an agreement, and the man wants to avoid jail time for sexually assaulting young girls. It doesn’t make sense for him to begin talking to Sophie’s friend and therapist.

Is Maggie’s stalker her new boyfriend, Cam Lam, in ‘A Million Little Things’?

A widespread fan theory is that Maggie’s new boyfriend, Camden Lamoureux (Ryan Hansen), might be stalking her.

“He’s very controlling and possessive, but keeping a tight lid on those behaviors,” another viewer wrote on Reddit. “In this last episode, they started to show. BF wants to scare Maggie into never being alone when he’s away, so he is always in control.”

The argument against Cam as the stalker is that he’s already her boyfriend and sees a lot of her. Why would he also send her creepy letters?

Could the stalker be an obsessed fan of Maggie’s new boyfriend?

Another theory viewers have about Maggie’s stalker is that it could be an ex-girlfriend or obsessed fan of Camden. That might explain why he does not want to go out on dates in public with Maggie. However, if it were someone that Camden knew, he would probably know from the letters. If it’s a fan of Cam, he’s publicist probably would alert him of similar letters. 


‘A Million Little Things’ Season 4 Episode 5 Recap, ‘Crystal Clear’ — The Truth is Out

Is it someone viewers haven’t met yet?

The most likely fan theory about Maggie’s stalker in A Million Little Things is that it’s someone viewers haven’t met yet. However, it could be someone they mentioned already.

“I think it’s going to be the new assistant at the radio station that we haven’t met yet,” another Redditor wrote. “They mention he drives WAY too nice a car for such a low-paying position, and that’s because he isn’t there because he needs the job; he is there to stalk Maggie.”

Could Maggie’s stalker be someone new at the radio station? According to the A Million Little Things Season 4 Episode 8 promo, things become more intense with her stalker.

A Million Little Things Season 4 airs at 10 p.m. EST on Wednesdays and the next day on Hulu.