‘A Million Little Things’ Season 4 Episode 3 Recap, ‘Game Night’ — More Questions

The A Million Little Things Season 4 Episode 3 recap of “Game Night” confirmed who called Eddie Saville (David Giuntoli) about his hit-and-run. However, things begin to look messy for Gary Mendez (James Roday Rodriguez) and his involvement in Peter Benoit’s (Andrew Leeds) attack. There’s no mention of Delilah (Stephanie Szostak) or Danny’s (Chance Hurstfield) trip to France for the second straight episode. Will Delilah and Danny ever return?

[Spoiler alert: This article contains spoilers from A Million Little Things Season 4 Episode 3 ‘Game Night.’]

A Million Little Things Season 4 Episode 3 Gary looks worried while talking on the phone in his car
‘A Million Little Things’: James Roday Rodriguez as Gary Mendez | Jack Rowand/ABC/Getty Images

Georgia gives Detective Saunders a tip to lead him straight to Gary

The episode opens with Anna Benoit (Erin Karpluck) by her husband, Peter Benoit’s bedside in the hospital. He’s still in a coma when Detective Craig Saunders (Brian Markinson) comes in to ask her a few more questions. When he asks whether she noticed anything odd leading up to the attack, she admits a man with a beard parked outside their home in a dark grey SUV. Anna also adds that Peter’s students love him dearly. 

However, later that evening, Mara sends her the link to Sophie’s (Lizzy Greene) guest appearance on Maggie’s (Allison Miller) podcast. In the A Million Little Things Season 3 finale, Sophie shared details about her sexual assault and told listeners Peter’s name.

‘A Million Little Things’ Season 4 Episode 3 recap: The Bruins party

The “Boys Night” in A Million Little Things Season 4 Episode 3 doesn’t go at all as the men planned. Gary and Eddie get overly excited about Theo (Tristan Byon) texting Shanice’s daughter, Kiana (Jaeda Owens), and he runs off embarrassed. Then Rome (Romany Malco) tosses his Bruins sweatshirt at Liam (Mattia Castrillo), and he jumps up to wash his hands. 

Plus, Gary can’t find his lucky Bruins hat that John Dixon (Ron Livingston) gave him during chemotherapy. Instead of watching the game, Gary, Rome, and Liam search for the hat. They end up driving to the place where Darcy (Floriana Lima) dropped off Gary’s donations. Although Liam overcomes his fear of germs to search for Gary’s hat, it’s not there. Later, the Bruins lose, and Gary admits he doesn’t deserve Darcy or Liam.  

RELATED: ‘A Million Little Things’ Season 4 Spoilers: Who Hit Eddie?

Meanwhile, Eddie takes Theo to Halpert’s to buy craft supplies for a grand gesture before Kiana leaves to visit her father in Los Angeles. Eddie comes across the blonde woman, Nicole (Rachel Nichols), who viewers think might be the one who hit him. Theo turns up before he can say anything, prompting Eddie to ask where they might find the glitter. Eddie did not listen to his new therapist, Russ’s (Michael Patrick Thornton) advice. Russ told Eddie earlier that even if he gets to speak to the person who hit him, it won’t change his life, and he will still be in a wheelchair.

Theo has his dad play music for his grand gesture while he reveals a message on signs like in Love Actually. Theo’s last two signs stick together, and he says the words “I really like you” aloud to Kiana. She returns the gesture, and the adorable young kids smile at each other. 

The Divorce Party gets awkward

The ladies throw Katherine a divorce party, and Shanice Williamson (Nikiva Dionne) makes a surprise appearance. Later the women, including Maggie, Darcy, and Regina (Christina Moses), play “Never Have I Ever” and laugh over how three of the women dated Gary. However, things get awkward when Darcy mentions trying to have a baby with Gary. Luckily, Sophie notices that Maggie is uncomfortable and steals her away to venture out for ice. 

When Darcy and Maggie suggest that Katherine begin to date again, the attorney gets upset. Shanice has a private heart-to-heart talk with Katherine about doing what she feels is right. So, Katherine tells Darcy and Maggie that she’s not ready to meet a guy at a bar, but she would love to stay in and play flip cup.

RELATED: ‘A Million Little Things’ Season 4 Cast: Are the Newcomers All Here to Stay?

Later, Shanice privately shares that she dated a woman after her divorce, not a man. However, she doesn’t want anyone to know because her parents wouldn’t be OK with it. Then Shanice brushes soap suds off Katherine’s face, and the two women quickly and awkwardly end the night. 

‘A Million Little Things’ Season 4 Episode 3 recap: Maggie, Sophie, and Georgia

When Maggie and Sophie pull up to the gas station in A Million Little Things Season 4 Episode 3, Sophie notices Peter’s wife, Anna, coming out of the store. Sophie extends her sympathy for Peter’s injuries, but Anna responds by accusing her of lying about her husband on the podcast. Sophie stands her ground and insists that she told the truth.

Afterward, Maggie and Sophie decided not to return to the party but instead shared their feelings over ice cream. Meanwhile, back at the hospital, Anna uses her husband’s finger to open his phone. At that exact moment, Peter’s eyes flutter as if he’s about to open them. 

RELATED: ‘A Million Little Things’ Season 4 Premiere Recap, ‘Family First’ and Burning Questions We Have After Episode 1

The last moments of ‘A Million Little Things’ Season 4 Episode 3, ‘Game Night’

In the last scene between Darcy and Gary, viewers can tell Darcy suspects something is up with her boyfriend. She recovered Gary’s favorite hoodie from the donation box, but he’s not excited to see it. He makes up a silly story about a wrestling game with his dog, Colin. However, fans can tell she knows he’s lying, and judging by the title of the next episode, “Pinocchio,” the truth is about to come out.

For the third week in a row, A Million Little Things ended with another tiny tidbit about Eddie’s hit-and-run. 

“My name is Nicole,” the caller from Halbert’s tells Eddie. “I want to tell you what happened that night.” 

Questions we still have after ‘A Million Little Things Season 4 Episode 3 ‘Game Night’

Are there feelings blossoming between Katherine and Shanice? Will the two become an item? Will Peter wake up in A Million Little Things Season 4 Episode 4? If he wakes up, will he remember what happened? Will Gary finally tell Darcy and his friends his involvement in Peter’s assault? Will viewers hear from Delilah and Danny? Wouldn’t Sophie have the occasional FaceTime with her mother and siblings?

According to IMDbA Million Little Things Season 4 airs Wednesdays at 10 p.m. EST on ABC and is available for streaming the next day on Hulu.

This article was updated on Oct. 7, 2021: The original article incorrectly cited Peter Benoit’s wife as Georgia. Peter’s wife is Anna Benoit, portrayed by Erin Karpluk.