Milo Ventimiglia Once Starred in Priyanka Chopra’s Music Video

Any hardcore This Is Us fan can name nearly every project each of the stars has been in. Mandy Moore wowed in A Walk to Remember. Sterling K. Brown impressed in The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story. Justin Hartley steamed up the set of The Young and the Restless. And Chrissy Metz terrified in American Horror Story.

But what about This Is Us patriarch, Milo Ventimiglia? It turns out we slept right through his starring role in former Miss World Priyanka Chopra‘s pop music video. Here’s a recap of the strange fever dream.

Priyanka Chopra had a pre-Nick Jonas music career

Milo Ventimiglia during the arrivals for the 25th Annual Critics' Choice Awards
Milo Ventimiglia | David Crotty/Patrick McMullan via Getty Images

While the world knows Chopra from her Bollywood days or her American crossover into the world of Quantico, she also had a brief pop career.

Between 2013 and 2014, Chopra released three songs to moderate success in the U.S. and India. Her EDM debut single, “In My City,” features Black Eyed Peas member and was the theme song for Thursday Night Football for a short time.

Next came “Exotic,” in which Chopra paired up with Mr. Worldwide, Pitbull. In an interview with Elle, Chopra explained her transition to music.

“Music was something that I have known even before I came to show business,” she said. “My dad is a surgeon, but he was on stage and stuff as a hobby, and I used to do it with him. So I grew up with a lot of music.”

“I want to be able to do everything,” Chopra continued. “And as a girl, we’re really great at multitasking anyway.”

For her third single, Chopra invited Ventimiglia to play the video’s romantic interest.

Ventimiglia starred in Chopra’s music video as her love interest

Chopra recruited Ventimiglia to be in her music video for “I Can’t Make You Love Me.” The song is a cover of Bonnie Raitt’s 1991 original from the Grammy-winning album Luck of the Draw. However, Chopra put an EDM spin on it.

“I probably discovered it after some stupid boy broke my heart,” Chopra told Billboard about the single. Interscope head Jimmy Iovine played her a demo of the track by Ester Dean in his office.

“Priyanka fell in love with it and jumped on it—it’s her favorite song of all time,” her manager, Anjula Acharia Bath, said.

As for twisting the ballad to EDM, Chopra has a soft spot for the genre.

“I like dabbling in different genres of anything that I do,” she said. “Even the films that I do. You know, I do action, I do comedy, I do all kinds of drama. So I think my album’s that too, hence EDM. I love EDM.”

“The video was definitely inspired by the actor in me,” Chopra added. She revealed her favorite part was throwing purple powder into Ventimiglia’s face, though she didn’t love being thrown into a pool for four different takes.

There’s no word on why Chopra wanted Ventimiglia for the role, but considering his good looks and talent he’s an obvious choice. However, Chopra said the video holds a deeper meaning.

“I don’t want girls to feel that just because a relationship ends — which most girls do because we invest so much in relationships — you have to feel destroyed and like life is over because it’s really not,” she told Elle.

Were there sparks between the pair during filming?

In a 2018 interview with Access Hollywood, Ventimiglia was confronted with the old Chopra video footage and asked whether the two felt any sparks on set.

“It’s all professional,” he said. “It’s like you make the magic moments when the cameras are rolling and all that.”

The co-hosts jokingly booed, and Ventimiglia added, “That’s my job.”

Now that we’re all on the same page about Chopra’s music career, we’re fully expecting a duet between Chopra and her husband, Nick Jonas. As for Ventimiglia, fans love him any way they can get him — even in music videos we never knew existed.