Skip to main content

Peter Weber got engaged to Hannah Ann Sluss during his Bachelor season. But the couple split before the finale after the pilot revealed he had unresolved feelings for Madison Prewett. However, Weber and Prewett ultimately decided that they are not a good fit and, now, the former bachelor is dating Kelley Flanagan (also from his season).

Victoria Fuller and Kelley Flanagan on Peter Weber's season of 'The Bachelor'
Victoria Fuller and Kelley Flanagan | John Fleenor via Getty Images

Kelley Flanagan and Madison Prewett

There’s been some drama between Flanagan and Prewett recently, thanks to how everything played out. According to Prewett, she and the attorney were “best friends” while filming.

“We were best friends actually. We were inseparable throughout the entire process, everyone joked we were the dynamic duo. Really leaned on each other through that entire thing… I remember even when I landed from Australia and got home she was one of the first people that I called. She was in group messages with me and my family. We were really really close and talked 24/7,” Prewett told former bachelorette Kaitlyn Bristowe in an interview on her podcast,  Off The Vine.

So when it came out that Weber and Flanagan had been spending time together after he and Prewett had decided to go their separate ways, Prewett was hurt she’d never received a text or call from Flanagan.

“I didn’t receive any kind of a heads-up or any sort of text or explanation of why. I’m not saying I necessarily deserve it but I kind of feel like I do, because we were best friends,” she said. “If the roles were reversed that would be the first thought that I’d have. I want to take it to this person first, I want them to hear it from me first.”

Prewett told Bristowe that she hasn’t spoken to [Flanagan] in a really long time.” So it seems the two probably aren’t “best friends” anymore.

Kelley Flanagan’s relationship with the rest of Peter Weber’s ‘Bachelor’ contestants

But where does Flanagan stand with the rest of the women from Weber’s season? Bachelor Nation will remember that the pilot’s cast didn’t exactly get along while filming. But they seem to be on better terms with one another post-season.

On May 2, Flanagan posted a couple of photos of her and some of the women from Weber’s season. Mykenna Dorn, Kelsey Weier, and Lauren Jones were all posing with the attorney in the throwback post. “Missing my chicks, can’t wait to see them when all of this is over! ❤️” read her caption.

“Pretty girls 💕” commented Lexi Buchanan from Weber’s season.

“beautiful babes 💛” wrote Victoria Paul.

When Weber posted a photo of him and Flanagan to announce that they’re officially together, a few women from the pilot’s season commented to wish the couple well.

Weier and Dorn congratulated the couple, as well as Alayah Benavidez.

“Cuties💕 love this for y’all 🙌🏻” she wrote.

While Flanagan and Prewett might not be on the best of terms right now, it seems much of the pilot’s Bachelor cast is still friends with the attorney. We’ll have to wait and see who actually hangs out together as things with the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic progress.

Read more: ‘Bachelor’ Fans Are Asking Colton Underwood If He and Cassie Randolph Are on a Break Since They’re No Longer Isolating Together