Skip to main content

Though it might not have come through during Peter Weber’s Bachelor season, Madison Prewett says that she and Kelley Flanagan were “best friends.”

In an interview that Prewett did with Kaitlyn Bristowe on her podcast, Off The Vine, she spoke about her relationship with the attorney.

Madison Prewett | Francisco Roman via Getty Images
Madison Prewett | Francisco Roman via Getty Images

Madison Prewett says she and Kelley Flanagan ‘were best friends actually’

“We were best friends actually. We were inseparable throughout the entire process, everyone joked we were the dynamic duo. Really leaned on each other through that entire thing… I remember even when I landed from Australia and got home she was one of the first people that I called. She was in group messages with me and my family. We were really really close and talked 24/7,” she said.

Of course, now, Weber and Flanagan are dating. When the photos first surfaced of Weber and Flanagan spending time together in Chicago, Prewett said she was “definitely hurt and thrown off by that whole situation.” She said that, just days before it got out that they were spending time together, Weber had been texting Prewett to get back together. Weber has since inferred that there’s more to the story than Prewett let on in her Off the Vine interview and former bachelor Nick Viall has called Prewett a liar. Fans have also criticized Prewett for her comments about Flanagan when they had already both dated Weber when they were on the show together.

Are Madison Prewett and Kelley Flanagan still friends?

It seems as though Prewett hasn’t spoken to Flanagan since she found out her friend was spending time with Weber. Prewett thinks the new couple’s timeline doesn’t add up.

I haven’t spoken to her in a really long time… I have heard things and I actually asked Peter about some of the things I’d kind of been hearing about him and Kelley while we were still trying to figure our thing out, just that there had been hangouts and meetups and conversations that had been going on while he was still with Hannah Ann and while he was also trying to figure things out with me,” she said. “I asked him those questions and I think it’s very interesting because his answers and her answers very much contradict the current situation that’s happening right now.”

Mostly, Prewett says she just expected a call or a text from Flanagan.

“I didn’t receive any kind of a heads-up or any sort of text or explanation of why. I’m not saying I necessarily deserve it but I kind of feel like I do, because we were best friends,” she said.

“If the roles were reversed that would be the first thought that I’d have. I want to take it to this person first, I want them to hear it from me first. Man, I don’t know. It’s one of those things that I’m like I’ll never fully understand people,” said Prewett.

It’s safe to say that, at least for now, Prewett and Flanagan probably still aren’t on the best of terms. But Weber and the attorney seem happy together and Prewett seems to be happy with the direction her life is going in, too.

Read more: ‘The Bachelor’: Madison Prewett Admits She ‘Probably Should’ve Shared [That She’s Waiting to Have Sex] Sooner’