Skip to main content

Today, Dick Van Dyke is best known for portraying Rob Petrie on the beloved sitcom, The Dick Van Dyke Show. While he eventually went on to star in the series, alongside Mary Tyler Moore, Van Dyke wasn’t exactly a shoo-in. Two other famed actors were seriously considered for the role before Van Dyke ultimately won out.

Carl Reiner was initially going to portray Rob Petrie

The Dick Van Dyke show was loosely based on Carl Reiner’s experience working on Your Show of Shows. Reiner was a head writer for the series, which ran from 1950 until 1954. Rob’s co-workers were based on people that Reiner had worked with. Rob’s boss, Alan Brady, was based on Sid Caesar.

Carl Riener with Dick and Tom Smothers
Carl Riener with Dick and Tom Smothers | CBS via Getty Images)

Initially, Reiner was going to portray the title character. According to Vanity Fair, he even filmed a pilot, but he wasn’t charismatic enough to take on the role. Instead of passing on the show entirely, producers decided to go back to the drawing board and consider other actors.

Johnny Carson was initially in the running to take on the lead role

Johnny Carson is best known for being a late-night host, but he would have spent years portraying Rob if things had worked out differently. Carson was a finalist during the initial casting of the show, and, reportedly, he did a good job, but Van Dyke’s time on Broadway helped him land the role over Carson.

Johnny Carson interviews Drew Barrymore
Drew Barrymore, and Johnny Carson | Gene Arias/NBCU Photo Bank

All turned out OK in the end. Carson ended up landing The Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson the year after The Dick Van Dyke Show premiered. He hosted the series from 1962 until 1992.

Dick Van Dyke’s charisma and physical comedy helped him win the role

Carson was a formidable opponent for the role, but Van Dyke’s Broadway background and penchant for physical comedy helped him win the part. According to Parade, Sheldon Leonard, the show’s producer, initially fought for Van Dyke to take on the role after he saw him in Bye, Bye Birdie.

Dick Van Dyke as Rob Petrie in 'The Dick Van Dyke Show'
Dick Van Dyke as Rob Petrie | CBS via Getty Images

Mary Tyler Moore Told a Lie to Get Cast as Laura Petrie on ‘The Dick Van Dyke Show’

The show’s cast ended up being perfect, and the series took home multiple awards during its five-season run. Reiner took home statues for his work on the series, as did Van Dyke and Moore. Rose Marie and Morey Amsterdam were both nominated for their work on the series, too. Marie took on the role of Sally Rogers, and Amsterdam portrayed Buddy Sorrell. Both worked with Rob as writers.