Skip to main content

Girl Meets Farm and Food Network star Molly Yeh’s tomato squash soup is a non-dairy delight. She got the recipe from husband Nick Hagen’s mother, whom she affectionately calls Eggmom, and it has been in rotation in her arsenal of recipes ever since. It stems from the days when Yeh’s husband did not eat dairy, and his mom created this delicious soup to make a creamy soup with non-dairy included.

Molly Yeh the star of Girl Meets Farm smiles for the camera.
Molly Yeh | Discovery Press/Food Network

Molly Yeh talks about this Hagen family original main dish and the origins of the family nickname

Yeh spoke of her mother-in-law’s creativity in devising this particular soup, which pairs tomatoes and butternut squash to create a filling main dish meal.

“Here’s a soup that’s an Eggmom original. It’s a tomato soup thickened with squash puree instead of cream. A remnant from when Eggboy didn’t do dairy,” Yeh explained of her tomato squash soup.

In the f.a.q. section of her blog, Yeh explains how Hagen earned his nickname Eggboy.

“He earned the name eggboy a while back when he was eating zillions of eggs a day. He’s since reduced that number, but we do love eggs, especially the ones from our chickens!”

This sweet nickname stuck not only for Hagen but his parents as well.

What are the ingredients for this non-dairy soup?

Molly Yeh uses butternut squash in many ways, including this innovative recipe for mac and cheese.

Molly Yeh republished the Hagen family recipe in her book Molly on the Range.

The soup includes the following ingredients. One butternut squash halved lengthwise and seeded, olive oil, kosher salt, and black pepper.

Also required are cinnamon, paprika, cayenne pepper, cloves, one onion, garlic, thyme, two 28 oz. cans fire-roasted tomatoes, a container of vegetable broth, and parmesan cheese to top.

This tomato squash soup can be paired with Yeh’s favorite main dish, Chicken Schnitzel, for a filling and warming combination.

How to make the ‘Girl Meets Farm’ star’s Tomato Squash soup

Molly Yeh’s Garlic and Onion Challah pairs wonderfully with her mother-in-law’s recipe for tomato squash soup.

‘Girl Meets Farm’: Molly Yeh’s Pumpkin Pie With Whipped Cream and Cinnamon Tastes Like a Pumpkin Spice Latte

Preheat the oven to 375 degrees.

Place the squash halves cut side up on a baking sheet and brush the insides with olive oil. Sprinkle with salt and pepper, then add cinnamon, paprika, cayenne, and cloves.

Bake the squash until a fork pokes easily into the center. This process should take around one hour in total.

In a large pot, heat the olive oil over a low flame.

Then add onion and salt, cooking until the onion is translucent.

Then add both the garlic and thyme, cooking for several minutes.

Following, transfer the mixture to a blender or food processor.

Add the two cans of tomatoes and their juices, and blend until smooth.

Return the mixture to the pot.

Scoop the insides out of the squash and place them into the blender with the vegetable broth. Puree until smooth.

Add the squash to the remaining ingredients in the pot and simmer the ingredients for around 20 minutes.

Serve soup drizzled with olive oil and grated Parmesan cheese.

The full recipe is available on the Food Network website.

Girl Meets Farm airs Sundays at 11 a.m. EST on the Food Network.