‘Grey’s Anatomy’: If George O’ Malley Never Died — Everything Would Have Changed

Diehard Grey’s Anatomy fans will never forget the tragic episode where George O’ Malley (T. R. Knight) died. He was only part of the show for five seasons; however, fans think they know what would have happened if he was never hit by that bus. 

'Grey's Anatomy' stars Kate Walsh, T. R. Knight, and Katherine Heigl
‘Grey’s Anatomy’ stars Kate Walsh, T. R. Knight, and Katherine Heigl | Bruce Glikas/FilmMagic

Why did George O’ Malley leave ‘Grey’s Anatomy’?

The decision for George O’ Malley to depart Grey’s Anatomy was because the actor who played his character, T. R. Knight, called it quits. The star’s ultimate reason for leaving stemmed from many different things.  

In 2007, you may remember that co-star Isaiah Washington, who played Preston Burke, reportedly used a homophobic slur to refer to Knight. After the incident, Washington was fired from the show. However, the actor never recovered from the issue enough to want to continue on the series.

RELATED: ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Fans Predict Which Character Will Exit the Show in Season 17

Knight left Grey’s Anatomy in 2009, citing a “breakdown in communication” with Shonda Rhimes. He also was upset that O’ Malley was getting a decreasing amount of screen time on the show. Plus, the conflict with Washington forced him to come out as gay publicly. 

George O’ Malley would have hit it off with April Kepner

April Kepner (Sarah Drew) joined Seattle Grace Mercy West Hospital in season 6 after the merge of the two hospitals. Since O’ Malley died at the end of season 5, the two characters never met. 

“He would’ve been close to April had they met,” one fan wrote on Reddit. “George would’ve been a really incredible trauma surgeon, too.”

View this post on Instagram

Got to meet the fantastic @thesarahdrew and see my pal Peebers (who you know as @officialjustinchambers) at The Rape Foundation benefit this past Sunday. (Link in bio) #Repost @thesarahdrew with @get_repost ・・・ On Sunday, I attended #therapefoundation annual brunch. It was a deeply moving experience. The founder of this incredible organization, #GailAbarbanel (5th pic) invited me to come to surprise one of the three courageous survivors who told her story. I was absolutely blown away by the courage and the resiliance of the three survivors who shared their stories on Sunday. I think storytelling is a powerful tool for creating empathy, building bridges, educating and igniting activism. These three survivors are all simply amazing. The statistics surrounding sexual assault are staggering. 1 in 5 women are victims of rape. 1 in 4 girls and 1 in 6 boys are sexually abused before the age of 18. This is a horrific epidemic. The #Rapetreatmentcenter and #stuarthouse are both places to go where every need is met for victims of sexual assault completely free of charge. I am amazed by the work they are doing and was honored to have had the chance to participate in this fundraising event. I also had the chance to hang with @t.r.knight (who is just so wonderful) and my dear friend @officialjustinchambers . And it was beautiful to hear from @jennifer.garner Who was being honored as well.

A post shared by T.R. Knight (@t.r.knight) on

RELATED: ‘Grey’s Anatomy’: This 1 Major Character Wouldn’t Be on the Show If It Wasn’t for George O’ Malley

Other fans quickly agreed that April and George would have been fast friends.

“I really could’ve seen him and April getting along and having a friendly competitive relationship while both were doing trauma.”

O’ Malley would have helped Alex Karev and Izzie Stevens’ relationship on ‘Grey’s Anatomy’

Fans also feel that O’ Malley’s relationship with Alex Karev (Justin Chambers) would have grown and changed. 

“I feel like if George was there in season 6, he could’ve been a mediator to Alex and Izzie [Katherine Heigl] when they had problems,” another fan added. “He could have told Alex to tell Izzie to come back when he told her to leave. Alex would’ve respected him for telling him to fight for him and Izzie.”

Fans also add that the course of Izzie’s career at the hospital would have changed if O’ Malley were still alive in season 6.

RELATED: ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Fans Think This 1 Underrated Character Should Narrate the Series Finale — Not Meredith Grey

“If George were still there, then Izzie would have stayed and never even been fired,” one fan wrote. “She made a mistake because she was nice, and Charles took advantage of her kindness. She mentioned George immediately before mistreating the patient.”

Right before Izzie gives a patient the wrong medication, she yells at Charles for not having each other’s backs in the hospital. She brings up how George threw himself in front of a bus to save someone. So, fans feel that Izzie wouldn’t have been thinking about her friend’s death; therefore, she would have never made a mistake.

“Season 6 would have just been way better if he had stayed,” another fan concluded.