‘Return to Amish’: Fans Think Maureen Got the Best Makeover

Like many of the seasons before it, season 6 of TLC‘s smash-hit Return to Amish came back with a new set of characters and a whole new storyline.

And so, through the season, we follow the two girls Rosanna Byler and Maureen Miller, as they toss away the inhibitions of their tight-knit Amish communities and go out to find their place in the modern English city.

By the end of the season, you can barely recognize girls. They’ve come a long way from the shy, reserved individuals, scared of the ‘creepy moving stairs’ at the airport in episode 1, and have grown a little bolder.

TLC logo above a set of chairs on a stage
TLC, home of ‘Return to Amish’ | Amanda Edwards/Getty Images

Ultimately we see them leave the comfort of their bland Amish clothes, let their hair down (literally), and adorn a whole new English look – short dress, makeup, and everything.

Naturally, fans were quick to compare the more dramatic transformation, with most proclaiming that Maureen got the best makeover of everyone.

Makeovers have always been a thing on the show

Makeovers are no new phenomenon in the Return to Amish series. It’s almost kind of like a rite of passage that cast members have to go through, saying their final goodbyes to their conservative Amish past and fully embracing the new world.

We’ve seen it with previous members like Sabrina, and even boys like ‘the Mennonite boy,’ Lowell, who go on and cut their hair, get a change of clothes (for the first time) and become totally different individuals.

It is always exciting to see them break off their cocoons of conservatism and transform into the figurative butterflies, or in this case, ‘dolled up English girls.’

This new season is no exception. In episode 10, both Rosanna and Maureen toss away their hats and minimalist dresses and finally get their English makeovers.

As you may expect, fans went on to compare the two, debating who got the better makeover. At the same time, there were some who had their reservations on the matter.

Maureen got the better makeup artist

In this season, Maureen asked her grandmother Ada to help her with the makeover. For the first time, she untangled her hair and had it straightened and curled up.

She then had her makeup done (which was forbidden by the Amish community) and put on a fresh pair of heels. To reveal the transformation, Ada threw a reveal party.

Overall, the before and after differences of both girls were huge, to say the least. And the general consensus was that they looked better than before.

But fans everywhere couldn’t help but feel that Maureen looked even more transformed than Rosanna. So much so that it had them doubting the show.

One fan said, “Maureen’s makeover was so good it literally made me question the validity of the show.”

Another said, “Maureen is definitely not Amish. It’s easy to debunk if you do some digging on Facebook.”

Naturally, this sparked a whole new conversation on whether Maureen was really as Amish as she claimed to be.

It also brought back the old discussion on whether Return to Amish is real or fake.

Maureen didn’t change that much

As we’ve seen, some fans weren’t completely convinced about the nature of Maureen’s transformation.

They pointed out that Maureen didn’t really change as much because she had been out of the Amish community for the better part of her life.

One fan on Reddit responded, saying, “I just viewed Maureen’s younger Facebook page, and it seems as though she’s ‘dressed English’ her Whole life.” She further added, “I shouldn’t have peeked behind the curtains.”

Another fan, also on Reddit pointed out that her old Facebook account has pictures of her being a normal teenager dating back as far as 2017, not to mention there are no details about her parents or birthday anywhere.

Still, these are all just speculations, and no official confirmation has been made by the cast member.


‘Return to Amish’: Are Sabrina and Jethro Still Together?

Regardless, from how she carried herself throughout the season and her knowledge of the Amish community’s mannerisms, you can’t deny that she definitely had an Amish origin.

Whether she left only recently or earlier on in her life, we’ll leave that to your imagination.

For more on this and other interesting stories about your favorite cast from the Return to Amish, be sure to check out the celebrity cheat sheet.