Selena Gomez or Hailey Bieber: Who Is Justin Bieber More Astrologically Compatible With?

Hailey and Justin Bieber have been married since 2018, but that doesn’t mean that fans of the singer don’t still hope for a reconciliation with his famous ex, Selena Gomez. 

What do the stars have to say about which partner is best for the musician? Is Justin Bieber more astrologically compatible with his wife Hailey or with his ex Selena? 

Here is which pair makes the stronger couple, according to astrology. 

Justin Bieber poses with one hand on his chin.
Justin Bieber | Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images for The Met Museum/Vogue

Justin Bieber is a Pisces

According to Famous Birthdays, Justin Bieber’s birthday is March 1, 1994. This makes him a Pisces with no cusp influences. 

Pisces people are sweet, graceful, and sympathetic. They can also be too idealistic, gullible, and passive-aggressive.

Pisces is the artist of the zodiac, so it’s no surprise that Justin Bieber works in a field that allows him to express his creativity. Most Pisces people work in the arts or have artistic hobbies, such as painting, dancing, or playing a musical instrument. 

The natural element correlated with Pisces is water, and water signs are usually sensitive, emotional, and intuitive. They care deeply about other people’s feelings, and they are also very emotionally self-aware. 

Other Pisces celebrities include Rihanna, Kurt Cobain, Drew Barrymore, Elliot Page, and Olivia Rodrigo.

Justin and Hailey Bieber pose in matching black outfits at the 2021 Met Gala.
Justin Bieber and Hailey Bieber | Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic

Hailey Bieber is a Sagittarius

Famous Birthdays tells us that Hailey Bieber was born on November 22, 1996. According to most Western astrologers, this birthdate makes Hailey a Sagittarius on the cusp of Scorpio. However, some sources say that November 22 falls under the date range for Scorpio. 

Some of the positive Sagittarius traits are intelligence, compassion, and a joyful disposition. A few of the negative qualities associated with Sagittarius are tactlessness, flakiness, and impatience. 

Sagittarius belongs to the fire element, and fire signs are typically fun-loving, passionate, and magnetic. They have colorful and vibrant personalities, and people are drawn to their warmth. 

Other famous Sagittarians include Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera, Taylor Swift, Miley Cyrus, and Billie Eilish. 

Selena Gomez poses in a strapless dress at an event.
Selena Gomez | Tibrina Hobson/Getty Images

Selena Gomez is a Cancer

Famous Birthdays says that Selena Gomez was born on July 22, 1992. This birthdate makes her just barely a Cancer since she is right on the cusp of being a Leo. The dates for the zodiac sign Leo start on July 23. 

Some of the positive Cancer traits include being nurturing, protective, and loving. On the negative side, they can be hyper-emotional, obsessive, and spiteful. Cancer is known as “the Mother” of the zodiac, as it is a very feminine sign with maternal tendencies. 

Like Pisces, Cancer is also a water sign, meaning that Selena Gomez is probably sensitive, intuitive, and emotional. 

Other famous Cancers include Ariana Grande, Khloé Kardashian, Tom Hanks, Lana Del Ray, and Jessica Simpson. 

Selena Gomez and Justin Bieber look into each other's eyes and smile at an event.
Selena Gomez and Justin Bieber | Steve Granitz/ Getty Images

Selena Gomez Skipped the Met Gala but People Screamed Her Name at Justin Bieber and His Wife, Hailey Baldwin

Justin Bieber is slightly more astrologically compatible with Selena Gomez than Hailey Bieber

According to astrology, Justin Bieber is highly compatible with both Hailey Bieber and Selena Gomez. But thanks to her sign’s natural element and modality, Gomez is slightly more compatible with Bieber than Hailey is. 

Pisces and Cancer are both water signs, and therefore innately compatible. Two zodiac signs with the same natural element tend to understand each other and get along better than two different elements. 

But as a fire sign, Hailey is still quite compatible with Justin’s water sign. As opposites, fire and water signs balance each other. Sagittarius can provide Pisces strength, support, and motivation, while Pisces gives Sagittarius a nurturing and calming influence. It’s particularly helpful that Hailey is a Sagittarius on the cusp of being a Scorpio since Scorpio is a water sign, and therefore innately compatible with Pisces.

Every sign has a spiritual or emotional “age” based on the order of the zodiac. Sagittarius is the last or oldest fire sign of the zodiac, while Pisces is the oldest sign of them all. This means that both Justin and Hailey are old souls with a mature outlook on life. They possess innate wisdom and share a similar worldview. 

Cancer is one of the youngest signs of the zodiac, which puts Selena Gomez at odds with old soul Justin Bieber. There may have been times in their relationship when she struggled to regulate her emotions or express herself maturely. However, Bieber might have delighted in her childlike fascination with the world, while she appreciated his nurturing tendencies. 

Each zodiac sign also has one of three modalities: cardinal, mutable, or fixed. The modalities tell us how the signs solve problems and interact with the world. Sagittarius and Pisces are both mutable signs, and mutable signs are adaptable and versatile. They are happy to let others take the lead, and they tend to react to problems by avoiding them or solving them through compromise. While it’s wonderful that both Sagittarius and Pisces are willing to negotiate, a couple consisting of two mutable signs may have trouble taking action or making decisions. 

Cancer is a cardinal sign, and cardinal signs are natural leaders. They like to tackle problems directly and come up with innovative solutions. As a cardinal sign, Selena Gomez could help mutable Justin Bieber make decisions and take action, while he could help her be more laid-back and compromising. 

Ultimately, Justin and Hailey Bieber are very astrologically compatible and equipped to have a long-lasting marriage. But Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez are just the tiniest bit more compatible.