Some ‘Love Island’ Fans Think Cash Should ‘Go Find Cinco’

The drama on Love Island isn’t over just because Melvin “Cinco” Holland Jr. was voted off. Cashay Proudfoot talked about him once again with Charlie Lynch. Now some fans think she should leave the show to be with Cinco.

[Spoiler alert: Spoilers for the Love Island USA Season 3 episode on Aug. 3!]

Cash talked about Cinco with Charlie on ‘Love Island’

RELATED: ‘Love Island’: Why Some Fans Are Calling Cash ‘Two-Faced’

The Aug 3 episode showed Charlie getting to know three new women who came to the villa. Meanwhile, Cash told the other women she wasn’t sure about their relationship because Charlie has been distant. Charlie admitted he’s been holding back because of the Cinco situation, but he wants time to figure things out.

“Charlie was like 100% when he walked into Casa Amor,” Cash said in an interview. “I think as we gotten back here, I can literally see him pulling back. And I can understand because yes, the Cinco thing for him was hard, and I understand that. But I just don’t think he’s realizing everything I gave up to be with him.”

Charlie and Cinco later had a conversation. Charlie told her he’s guarding himself because he doesn’t want to be hurt. “You’re not being super understanding with my situation with Cinco,” she told him. “Like I could have kept him here. They would have all agreed with it,” she said.

Charlie told her he would have ended things if she did keep him. The episode ended with their issues not resolved. 

Some ‘Love Island’ fans think Cash should ‘go find Cinco’

RELATED: ‘Love Island’: Cinco Claims He’s Willing to Fight for 1 Woman

Some fans weren’t happy with what Cash had to say in the newest episode. They shared their thoughts in a Reddit thread, and multiple people thought she should leave for Cinco.

“CASH just freaking go home and go find Melvin,” one fan wrote. “Cash your man is outside the villa. Go get him girl!” another person wrote.

Other fans pointed out that Cash isn’t over Cinco. “Cinco living rent free in Cash’s mind and he’s not even in the villa,” one fan wrote. “Cash should have picked cinco,” another one wrote.

Cinco answered if he’d date Cash after ‘Love Island’

Cashay Proudfoot and Melvin Cinco Holland Jr. sitting on a couch on 'Love Island'
Cashay Proudfoot and Melvin Cinco Holland Jr. on ‘Love Island’ season 3 episode 4 | Sara Mally/CBS/Getty Images

RELATED: ‘Love Island’: Shannon and Genevieve Reportedly Had Drama Before the Show

Cinco is now back at home. He answered some fan questions on Instagram including if he’d date Cash after the show.

“We’ll see when she gets out,” he wrote. Fans also asked why he went back and forth between Cash and Trina Njoroge. He claimed he wasn’t sure of Cash’s feelings, so he left her for Trina. “If I knew how she truly felt earlier, things might have been different,” he said.