Skip to main content

Almost a year after Evan Smith proposed to Morgan Lolar, the Temptation Island couple has seemingly parted ways after cheating allegations. While Morgan has been more public about her grieving process, Evan has stayed off social media. He recently returned to Instagram to show off his new half-sleeve tattoo.

Morgan Lolar Evan Smith
Morgan Lolar, Evan Smith | Mario Perez

Evan Smith and Morgan Lolar seemingly broke up

The couple first met on USA Network’s Temptation Island, where Evan Smith arrived with his longtime girlfriend, Kaci Campbell. Even though he originally came to the island to prove his loyalty to Kaci, he quickly fell for Morgan after he chose her for the second date.

Their relationship progressed, and Evan asked Morgan to be his girlfriend, before breaking up with Kaci. Additionally, Evan declined to send Kaci a 30-second video and explain that he wanted to end the relationship.

Therefore, Kaci found out about his feelings towards Morgan in clips at weekly bonfires. Even so, she didn’t move on and pursue any of the guys in the house as she still wanted to stay with Evan. However, at their Final Bonfire, Evan expressed he wanted to leave the island with Morgan, breaking Kaci’s heart.

After the show, Evan moved to Arlington, Virginia and lived with Morgan, and then proposed to her only six months later in March 2019. The couple were seemingly happy and in love until Morgan suddenly wiped all pictures including Evan, from her Instagram account on January 2, 2020.

She avoided questions about the potential breakup and even uploaded a photo of her wearing her ring to her Instagram story. However, a week later, she confirmed the rumors and accused her fiance of cheating.

The two announced they were moving to California together, and Morgan tweeted she was “packing up her house and driving across the country” only a few days before she made the cheating accusations.

However, she still seems to live in Virginia while Evan is in California, allegedly having “nightly sleepovers with 21-year-olds” and ignoring Morgan.

A couple of weeks after the former cheerleader announced the assumed breakup, both couples had removed their names from their Instagram bios, deleted the saved stories from their time on Temptation Island, and unfollowed each other on all social media platforms.

Evan still has his pictures with Morgan visible on his account, except for one announcing their engagement.

Evan Smith got a tattoo amid breakup

While Morgan has been incredibly vocal with her feelings regarding the possible breakup, Evan has remained relatively quiet. He hasn’t been active on Twitter since Christmas Eve, when they were last on good terms, and hasn’t uploaded anything to his Instagram.

On January 22, 2020, Evan returned from his Instagram hiatus and uploaded a picture of his new half-sleeve tattoo, which featured a wolf and flowers, to his story. He didn’t explain why he chose a wolf, but common interpretations are the animal symbolizes strength, power, and resilience.

Although Evan has a few other tattoos including the phrase, “I am my brother’s keeper” on his side, and the date his father passed away in Roman Numerals on his wrist, the half-sleeve is seemingly his largest tattoo as of yet.