Skip to main content

It has been almost a week since fans watched the finale of Season 10 of Bachelor in Paradise. While the show just wrapped up for viewers, it’s been a little while since the cast returned home from filming the dating competition in Costa Rica. While time has tempered some drama, it has not squashed some of the season’s biggest battles. In fact, Allyshia Gupta seems to have grown more incensed the longer she spends away from Kat Izzo. Allyshia Gupta is so deeply bothered by the Bachelor Nation alum that she took to a reunion special to claim she had the “best FBI agent” in California ready to give Kat a polygraph test. Fans of the series think she’s taken it too far, and by the look on his face, so does Spencer Conley.

Allyshia Gupta claims she dislikes Kat Izzo because she ‘decieved’ everyone

Allyshia Gupta appeared on the beach later in the game than the other finalists. She made quick work of finding someone willing to give her a rose and appeared interested in working with Sean McLaughlin, though it was clear she had her eye on someone else. Still, no one is convinced the pair had a romantic connection. Instead, they acted as a team hellbent on destroying Kat Izzo. Allyshia and Sean returned to the beach in the final moments of the show to accuse Kat of having a relationship back at home while she was allegedly trying to find love on TV.

A close-up of Kat Izzo in 'Bachelor in Paradise' Season 9
Kat Izzo in ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ Season 9 | ABC/Craig Sjodin

The competition partners insisted they had receipts of Kat’s deception, although they didn’t produce any. Ultimately, the big reveal garnered little attention or concern. Since the finale, Allyshia’s feelings for Kat haven’t changed. She has insisted, during multiple podcast interviews, that she thinks Kat is a bad person. She points at her “deception” as the cause of her hatred. Her distaste feels a bit misplaced, though. Still, she used the recent reunion podcast to double down on her hatred of Kat.  

She used the ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ reunion to ask Kat to take a polygraph test

The Bachelor in Paradise reunion looked a bit different this year than in the past. Hosted by Wells Adams, the check-in was recorded in podcast format. Unlike in past seasons, this season’s reunion was not heavily formatted. The cast was given ample time to speak freely, and they happily used it. Allyshia Gupta used her free time during the season 10 Bachelor in Paradise reunion to ask Kat Izzo to take a polygraph test. Kat agreed, but we suspect she might have just been calling her bluff.

While discussing the drama over whether Kat had someone at home she was communicating with in secret, Allyshia Gupta asked Kat if she was willing to take a polygraph as she had an “appointment” with the “best FBI agent” in the state set for the following morning. Whether or not Allyshia knows someone qualified to give a polygraph test doesn’t really matter. Fans were flummoxed by the ridiculousness of the statement.

Spencer Conley’s face said it all

Allyshia Gupta’s statement about polygraphs and FBI agents shocked and confused almost everyone who tuned in. Viewers flocked to Reddit and other social media platforms to discuss the odd turn of events. While most Bachelor Nation matters have fans on both sides of the debate, almost everyone is in agreement this time. Most fans agree that Gupta looked downright crazy with her generic “FBI agent” claims and request for a polygraph test over a situation that only she and Sean McLaughlin seem to still care about.

Spencer Conley proposes to Jess Edwards during the finale of 'Bachelor in Paradise' season 10
Spencer Conley and Jess Edwards | Disney/Bahareh Ritter

The whole cast might have been confused by the ask, but Spencer Conley’s face said what everyone was thinking. Spencer, who won the season with his fiancée, Jess Edwards, along with another Andrew Spencer and Alexe Godin, was seated directly in front of Allyshia. He was in the shot in the YouTube video as Allyshia delivered her request for Kat to take a polygraph test. We are glad he was. His face was priceless. He looked incredulous as Allyshia insisted she had an appointment set with the “best” FBI agent in California. It appears that Spencer, along with the fanbase, isn’t sure the government would worry themselves with reality TV drama.