Skip to main content

Hailey Bieber and Justin Bieber have been married for years now, but fans still haven’t quite gotten over their very messy and very complicated relationship timeline. Hailey just drew attention to that timeline again with a post about the number of New Year’s moments she and Justin have had together. Now, commentary around Justin and Selena Gomez’s many breakups has reignited. Gomez, who married Benny Blanco in September, is staying quiet, but her fans are not.

Hailey Bieber rang in a new year with a sentimental Instagram post

Hailey Bieber and Justin Bieber’s relationship has been under a microscope from the start. All along, Justin has claimed he wanted privacy. His now-wife has been open about showing off their romance on social media. To ring in the new year, she penned a sentimental Instagram Story about spending the last 10 New Year’s holidays with her husband.

The post was sweet, and the couple’s relationship appears to be on an upswing after months of tension. Still, fans were quick to notice that the math isn’t exactly mathing. The Biebers got married after a whirlwind romance that started just a few months before their courthouse wedding. Fans think Hailey Bieber accidentally revealed she was waiting in the wings while Justin Bieber was still with his ex-girlfriend.

What does Hailey Bieber and Justin Bieber’s relationship timeline really look like?

Fans noted that Hailey Bieber might have just told on herself by claiming to have been with Justin Bieber for 10 New Year’s celebrations. It looks like, based on the number of years she claims they’ve been celebrating the new year together, that there was significant overlap between her romance with Justin and Justin’s love affair with Selena Gomez. To be fair, Hailey didn’t reveal anything that fans didn’t already know; the couple’s relationship timeline is messy. That was never a big secret.

Justin Bieber and his now-wife sparked dating rumors in mid-2015 when they were spotted hanging out. While they appeared to ring in the new year together for 2016, their romance didn’t last all that long. By the spring, they weren’t dating any longer after Justin suggested he wasn’t looking to rush into anything.

Related

Justin Bieber’s Instagram Activity Suggests He Has Feelings About Selena Gomez’s Engagement

Bieber went on to date other women. He even reconnected with Selena Gomez before being spotted, once again, with Hailey in mid-2018, just weeks after Justin was spotted in Jamaica with Selena. They have been together ever since, marrying quickly in September 2018. Based on the timeline of events, Justin and Hailey Bieber have spent eight consecutive New Year’s Eves together, not 10. If you include the one year they were casually dating, they’ve been together for nine special events, not 10. Unless, of course, there was more overlap between Selena and Hailey than fans initially thought