Skip to main content

3 ‘Friends’ Spinoffs That Fans Think Could Have Worked

'Friends' fans might not have loved 'Joey' as a 'Friends' spinoff, but they weren't against the idea of another show. In fact, there are three show concepts that they think could have worked a lot better. Viewers would have watched a series about Ross and Rachel, Gunther, and even Monica and Ross' grandmother.

The Friends reunion was a success by many metrics. Still, the HBO Max variety special left fans wanting more. The show’s most loyal viewers have been desperate to see more from the group of characters they came to know and love or, at the very least, learn more about their stories. The reunion did not deliver on that, nor did the show’s failed spinoffJoey. There are several spinoffs that fans are certain could have worked, though. Did Marta Kauffman and David Crane miss an opportunity? 

Could a Ross and Rachel spinoff have worked? 

Joey Tribbiani was the main character who got a spinoff when Friends ended. The show wasn’t exactly a success, regardless of Matt LeBlanc’s expert portrayal of the beloved character. So why didn’t it work? Some fans think Joey failed because it only included one main cast member. Even though Joey was a fan favorite, Friends purists seem to think a series about Ross Geller and Rachel Green would have been far more successful. 

Jennifer Aniston and David Schwimmer pose together drinking a milkshake during a promotional shoot for 'Friends'
Jennifer Aniston and David Schwimmer | NBCU Photo Bank/NBCUniversal via Getty Images

So, why would Ross and Rachel’s story make the most sense? Simply put, they were the original will-they-won’t-they couple. Friends fans were invested in their love story from season 1, and that interest continued through the show’s final episode. When fans last left them, Ross and Rachel were finally figuring things out. Seeing that relationship come to fruition would have garnered interest, at least for a while. 

Fans insist Gunther from ‘Friends’ could have had his own show 

Gunther was far from a main character, but he did orbit the group and served an important role. Gunther was also mysterious and appeared to have a pretty interesting life that Friends‘ writers never covered during the show’s 10-season run. Fans insist that a spinoff that followed him onto a new adventure would have done well. Perhaps, Gunther could have found his way back into acting, and the hypothetical spinoff could have followed him as he balanced the coffeehouse and his budding career. 

Gunther talks to Ross during the 'The One Where Emma Cries' episode of 'Friends'
Gunther and Ross in ‘Friends’ | Danny Feld/NBCU Photo Bank

Aside from being a mysterious character on the group’s periphery, his side character status in Friends makes a spinoff about him more likely to succeed. A Reddit user points out that the most successful spinoffs have focused on side characters from a show instead of the main cast members. Frasier and Better Call Saul are prime examples.

A ‘Friends’ spinoff about Ross and Monica’s grandmother could have garnered interest

Some fans insist that a spinoff about the main characters couldn’t work because the magic was the ensemble. The sentiment is sound. It’s largely believed Joey didn’t work for this very reason. That doesn’t mean the Friends story needed to end, though. TV Guide suggests a prequel about Ross and Monica Geller’s grandmother could have garnered serious interest.

Matt LeBlanc as Joey Tribbiani, Courteney Cox as Monica Geller, Matthew Perry as Chandler Bing, Lisa Kudrow as Phoebe Buffay, Jennifer Aniston as Rachel Green and David Schwimmer as Ross Geller sit on a steel beem for a promotional photo shoot for 'Friends'
The cast of ‘Friends’ | NBCU Photo Bank/NBCUniversal via Getty Images

‘Friends’: Monica and Rachel’s Apartment Number Makes No Sense

It makes perfect sense when you think about it. In an early episode, Monica finds a picture of her grandmother with a group of friends at a coffeehouse named Java Joes. Their grandmother, who had once resided in Monica’s apartment, was in her twenties and had a group of friends, just like the gang. The prequel could have filled in the blanks and explained how the Friends gang came to be. A period-specific series would have set it apart from the original, too.