Who Has ‘Jersey Shore’s DJ Pauly DelVecchio Dated Before?

With all of the speculation surrounding Double Shot at Love‘s Pauly DelVecchio and Nikki Hall’s relationship, many fans are curious about who DelVecchio has dated in the past. Historically, DelVecchio has always been the single roommate on Jersey Shore, so his dating track record might surprise you!

Pauly DelVecchio
Pauly DelVecchio | Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images

Pauly D hooked up with several ‘Jersey Shore’ roommates 

In addition to the random women DelVecchio had relations with on Jersey Shore, he also hooked up with several of his roommates. The first was Jenni “JWoww” Farley, who was dating her boyfriend at the time, Tom Lippolis. DelVecchio also hooked up with Deena Cortese during the cast’s trip to Italy in season 4. 

According to a former producer who worked on the first couple seasons of Jersey Shore, DelVecchio also hooked up with Angelina Pivarnick. “During a promotional trip — it was either in LA or New York, but I think it was LA — [Angelina] hooked up with Pauly,” they shared on Reddit. Despite his many in-house hookups, DelVecchio never dated any of his roommates.

Pauly D had a one-night-stand with Amanda Markert 

DelVecchio met Amanda Markert in August 2012. At the time, she was working VIP bottle service at The Pool After Dark nightclub in Atlantic City. The two had a one-night-stand that resulted in pregnancy. In May 2013, DelVecchio’s daughter Amabella Sophia Markert was born.

DelVecchio is a proud father to Amabella, who remains an essential part of his life. “She’s a mini-me — I already have her on the turntables,” Delvecchio told Live With Kelly and Ryan in April 2019. “I look at her, and I see myself. She’s a Prank War Champion, too!” 

DJ Pauly D had a toxic relationship with Aubrey O’Day

DelVecchio met the Danity Kane singer on the reality series Famously Single in 2015. They were only together for a year and a half, calling their relationship off in July 2017. When the duo appeared on Marriage Boot Camp: Reality Stars, many of the issues in their relationship were brought forward. 

More recently, O’Day opened up about her relationship with DelVecchio on MTV’s Ex On The Beach. “I told a lot of truth about my experience with Pauly,” O’Day explained. “I had such a toxic, unhealthy, abusive situation with him. I needed a year and two months of therapy to find myself and I would never want to see him again. I think the fear in my stomach of him [showing up as an ex] was real.”

‘Double Shot at Love’ allowed Pauly to date multiple women at once 

When MTV announced Double Shot at Love, fans were excited for DelVeccchio to find a girlfriend. Throughout season 1, there were several prospects that he seemed interested in. At the end of the season, it came down to Nikki Hall and Derynn Paige. After DelVecchio let Paige go, Hall thought that meant DelVecchio was choosing her as his partner. However, that wasn’t the case. “I’m rolling solo for now,” he told Hall, who left the house in tears. 

It seems like Pauly D has made amends with Nikki 

Despite what is going on in season 2 of Double Shot at Love, many fans have speculated that Hall and DelVecchio are a couple. TMZ reported that the two were giving their relationship “another shot” in December 2019. More recently, eagle-eyed fans on Reddit spotted what appeared to be DelVecchio’s Las Vegas home in the background of a video Hall posted to her Instagram Stories.


‘Jersey Shore’: Why Fans Are Against Jenni ‘JWoww’ Farley and Pauly DelVecchio Dating

Neither Hall nor DelVecchio has outwardly shared anything hinting that they are in a relationship. However, the two have been extra flirty on social media. After DelVecchio commented on Hall’s recent video post, she replied: “If they don’t, they’re missing out — besides, I like you better with no clothes on.” Only time will tell if the two are truly a couple.