How Real Is ‘Grey’s Anatomy’?
One of the longest-running and most popular shows on television, Grey’s Anatomy, has become the gold standard for medical dramas. It is responsible for launching the careers of many top stars: Ellen Pompeo, Sandra Oh, Patrick Dempsey, and Eric Dane.
Audiences have grown attached to the many characters over the years, and many fans credit the show for helping them to learn a great deal about the medical field. However, as it turns out, the show takes a good deal of dramatic creative liberties with what happens inside the hospital doors.
What is ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ about?
Grey’s Anatomy premiered in 2005 and focused on a large group of doctors, interns, and residents, who work at the fictional Seattle Grace Hospital. In later seasons the hospital was renamed as Grey-Sloan Memorial Hospital. The show follows the personal lives and work struggles of the varied main cast but centered on Meredith Grey. Grey’s journey from intern to physician has been documented over the years, and Ellen Pompeo has been recognized multiple times for her portrayal of the accomplished doctor.
In addition to the ethnically diverse casting, Grey’s Anatomy has often made headlines for the radical changes in cast members over the years. In spite of frequent new faces on the show, it has maintained its status as one of the biggest TV shows around, year after year. Now in its fifteenth season, Grey’s Anatomy is still incredibly popular and is showing no signs of disappearing anytime soon.
Is ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ realistic?
While Grey’s Anatomy is definitely entertaining and can hold audience interest in a way that few other medical dramas can, the general consensus is that it isn’t very accurate to real life. A recent study compared happenings in actual hospitals versus the events portrayed on Grey’s Anatomy, and the results were none too pretty.
In addition to creating unrealistic expectations of the experience that patients can expect at a hospital, the report also claims that the show doesn’t accurately portray the status of interns or physicians. Frequently on Grey’s Anatomy, interns will bypass physicians and surgeons in matters relating to patient care, which on the show lead to life-saving results — in real life, not so much.
Some reports also take issue with the laid-back way that the hospital itself is represented, with characters having romantic encounters in various locations and generally not behaving in a professional manner. Of course, the show tends to glamorize the hospital patients themselves as well, with many of the patients portrayed as young, attractive women. Discharge times are often much shorter than average in Grey’s Anatomy, and the show tends to focus on rare diseases and maladies rather than more common ailments like broken legs or flu.
What do actual doctors think of ‘Grey’s Anatomy’?
So Grey’s Anatomy isn’t medically accurate — but does it do damage to the life-saving work that doctors and nurses perform on a daily basis? A recent article broke down the disconnect between what audiences see on TV in doctor shows and compared it to their experiences in a doctor’s office or hospital. Several physicians were interviewed, and their opinions seem crystal clear. One doctor claimed that when patients have a certain idea of what to expect, which they’ve based on TV shows like Grey’s Anatomy, they can often feel frustrated by their real-life experiences, which in turn can make it more difficult for doctors and nurses to provide proper care.
It is important to remember that TV shows like Grey’s Anatomy are meant to provide entertainment and not medical advice. As long as fans of the show are able to make that distinction between fiction and reality, they should never have any problems when they have to turn to real medical professionals.