‘Survivor’: How to Spot a Winner’s Edit
- The editors of Survivor play a major role in determining how each season’s story unfolds.
- What is a winner’s edit?
- How to spot a winner’s edit on Survivor.
Survivor isn’t just the original reality TV competition show. Yes, each week is filled with challenges and tribal councils, where members are voted off one by one. But each season actually tells a story via editing, based on who is eventually named sole survivor.
Do you want to know who wins before Jeff Probst reads the final vote? Here’s how to spot a winner’s edit on Survivor.
The ‘Survivor’ editors determine how each season’s story is told
As Survivor YouTuber Once Upon An Island says, “Every season of Survivor is a story. There are main characters, sidekicks, comic reliefs, and villains. A good season of Survivor tells a compelling story that has you rooting for someone and against someone else.”
If the season is edited correctly to reveal the most important parts and make sense of the outcome of each episode, viewers will want to keep watching to see what happens next. And by the end, they’ll get a satisfying conclusion.
The power of the storytelling is in the hands of Survivor editors. The contestants are filmed 24/7 for up to 39 days. That’s hundreds of hours of footage that must be edited down to approximately 15 one-hour episodes. But there must be a purpose behind each edit, and a strategy for what’s presented to viewers based on who wins the season and the angle of the story they want to tell.
What is a ‘winner’s edit’?
According to Survivor YouTuber Peridiam, a “winner’s edit” on Survivor is described as “the edit the winning player of any season of Survivor receives.” However, a fable has emerged among fans over the past 20+ years that theorizes the winner of a season can be spotted early based on specific editing techniques.
Because Survivor isn’t scripted, the editors have to figure out how to tell each season’s story with an overarching narrative based on the characters who are playing and who eventually wins. This approach will cause primary players and secondary players to emerge. Sometimes, it will also result in nearly invisible players.
There’s also story beats like blindsides that end up being turning points in key relationships among the alliances.
How to spot a winner’s edit on ‘Survivor’
Because the season is edited after all the footage is shot, the editors know who the winner is before the process begins. This is important because that one player must be featured in some way throughout the entire season — starting with episode one — so the audience knows who they are, who they’re working with, and what their thoughts are on certain events.
In the first episode of a season, fans should be aware of which players get confessionals directly to the camera. As a rule, the winner of the season will appear in a confessional in the season premiere. And more often than not, fans will hear a “winner quote.” Which is usually a declaration that they will win the game or the $1 million.
For example, in season 21 Survivor: Nicaragua, eventual winner Jud “Fabio” Birza told the camera in the episode 1, “I don’t care what they call me, I’m gonna win the million dollars. So, I guess my nickname’s Fabio.”
Even Richard Hatch in season 1 told the camera during the premiere, “I’ve got the one million dollar check written already. I’m the winner.”
When looking for a winner’s edit, fans should listen for players describing their strategy during the first episode. There is often heavy foreshadowing that will give fans a clue of what’s to come.
Editors are trying to explain how 1 person will win the season
Fans looking for a winner’s edit should be aware that editors are trying to explain to the audience how this one person won the season. Are they a frontrunner from the beginning? Did they go on an immunity streak to advance them further in the game? Maybe they were an underdog who started off in the middle of the pack.
No matter what the winner’s storyline is, viewers should be aware that whoever is named sole survivor will get the winner’s edit. But, there’s also the possibility of a “decoy winner’s edit” to throw viewers off.
There are exceptions to these rules. But once you start noticing them, chances are you will be able to figure out who the winner will be. Peridiam advises to look at the key tenets of a winner’s edit as a checklist. The more items that are checked off, the more likely it is that you’re looking at the winner.
The key tenets of a ‘Survivor’ winner’s edit
The first key tenet of a Survivor’s winner edit is a “winner quote” in the premiere episode. Next, according to Peridiam, the winner’s confessional in the premiere episode should “highlight the player as a person, as an individual, and relay that back to the game.”
Ultimately, when looking for a winner’s edit, the story will explain why the winner is making the moves that they are. Editors will frame the winner’s story so that viewers will get their perspective on major moves in the game. Either directly from the winner’s mouth or from another player explaining the eventual winning player’s viewpoint.
The final clue of a winner’s edit is “narrative precedence,” or being the most important person in the story sequence in a scene. The most glaring example was during Survivor: Kaôh Rōng and the edit given to winner Michele Fitzgerald when she blew the first challenge after the merge.
The order of what’s being shown to viewers, why they are showing it, and what’s being said is something fans should pay attention to. If they do, the power ranking order of the players will eventually become clear.
Survivor 41 airs Wednesday nights on CBS.