The Beatles’ ‘Ticket to Ride’: How the Carpenters’ Cover ‘Foreshadowed’ ‘(They Long to Be) Close to You’
The Beatles and the Carpenters are very different artists; however, the Carpenters covered The Beatles’ “Ticket to Ride” and released their cover as a single. Richard Carpenter revealed what he did to transform the original Beatles song from an upbeat rock song into a ballad. The public reaction to the Carpenters’ version of the track was very different from the public reaction to The Beatles’ version.
Why the Carpenters’ Richard Carpenter thought The Beatles’ uptempo songs worked as ballads
On his website, Richard Carpenter writes he and Karen Carpenter signed with A&M Records in 1969. He said their debut album, Offering, was a product of the mainstream pop music of the time. It had some elements of the Carpenters’ distinct sound; however, the group also drew inspiration from other artists like The Mamas & the Papas, We Five, Harry Nilsson, The Beach Boys, and Buffalo Springfield.
Offering also included a cover of The Beatles’ classic hit “Ticket to Ride.” “‘Ticket to Ride’ is one of our finest tracks,” Carpenter wrote. “Since many of The Beatles’ up-tempo songs are as melodic as the ballads, they can be made, with the right approach, into ballads as well.”
How the Carpenters turned an upbeat Beatles song into a ballad
Carpenter said he and Karen helped make the song sound sad together. “Not only did I slow the piece down, but changed, or added, some chord changes as well, along with the melody at the end of the choruses, with Karen resolving on a very effective major seven,” he wrote. “This put her in her marvelous lower register on the word ‘care,’ which sounds terrific and adds to the plangent character of the entire chart; after all ‘Ticket to Ride’ is a sad lyric.
Carpenter said the cover prefigured the Carpenters’ version of “(They Long to Be) Close to You.” “The arrangement ends with a tag of four part harmony (overdubbed, 12 voices in all) singing ‘Think I’m gonna be sad’ that foreshadows the happier ‘wah’ tag that I would later fashion for the ending of ‘Close to You,'” Carpenter wrote.
The way the world reacted to those 2 versions of ‘Ticket to Ride’
The Beatles’ version of “Ticket to Ride” peaked at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100, remaining on the chart for 11 weeks. Its parent album, Help!, was a hit as well. Help! reached No. 1 on the Billboard 200, staying on the chart for 46 weeks.
The Carpenters’ version of “Ticket to Ride” was a success as well — albeit a minor success. It reached No. 54 on the Billboard Hot 100, staying on the chart for 12 weeks. According to the Carpenters’ website, the song’s parent album was originally titled Offering: however, it was later renamed Ticket to Ride because of the minor success of the Carpenters’ cover. Ticket to Ride reached No. 150 on the Billboard 200, staying on the chart for 16 weeks. The Carpenters made “Ticket to Ride” their own — but the public undeniably preferred The Beatles’ version.