Skip to main content

[SPOILER ALERT: Spoilers ahead for The Challenge: All Stars 3.]

MJ Garrett and Jonna Mannion are fresh off their The Challenge: All Stars 2 win and have both reportedly returned for the following season to defend their crown, according to popular spoiler account, PinkRose. Who else is competing, and who won All Stars 3?

The cast of 'The Challenge XXX' sitting down on a stage
The cast of ‘The Challenge XXX’ on stage during the Q & A and Reception | Lars Niki/Getty Images

Jonna Mannion and MJ Garrett return for ‘The Challenge: All Stars 3’ to defend their crown

Nia Moore (The Real World: Portland)
2 seasons

Sylvia Elsrode (The Real World: Skeletons)
2 seasons, 1 final

Kailah Casillas (The Real World: Go Big or Go Home)
5 seasons, 1 final

Laterrian Wallace (Road Rules: Maximum Velocity Tour)
5 seasons, 1 final

Melinda (Stolp) Collins (The Real World: Austin
5 seasons, 1 final

Beth Stolarczyk (The Real World: Los Angeles)
8 seasons, 1 final

Kellyanne Judd (The Real World: Sydney)
5 seasons, 2 finals

Tina Barta (Road Rules: South Pacific)
6 seasons, 2 finals

Jemmye Carroll (The Real World: New Orleans 2
8 seasons, 2 finals

Cynthia Roberts (The Real World: Miami
2 seasons, 1 win

Kendal (Sheppard) Darnell (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)
3 seasons, 1 win

Nehemiah Clark (The Real World: Austin)
6 seasons, 1 win

Syrus Yarbrough (The Real World: Boston)
6 seasons, 1 win

Jonna Mannion (The Real World: Cancun)
7 seasons, 1 win

Brad Fiorenza (The Real World: San Diego)  
11 seasons, 1 win

Roni Martin (Road Rules: Northern Trail)
3 seasons, 2 wins

Maxie “MJ” Garret (The Real World: Philadelphia
4 seasons, 2 wins

Yes Duffy (Road Rules: Semester at Sea)
4 seasons, 2 wins

Tyler Duckworth (The Real World: Key West)  
5 seasons, 2 wins

Mark Long (Road Rules: First Adventure)
7 seasons, 2 wins

Wes Bergmann (The Real World: Austin
14 seasons, 2 wins

Jordan Wiseley (The Real World: Portland)
6 seasons, 3 wins

Veronica Portillo (Road Rules: Semester at Sea)
11 seasons, 3 wins

Derrick Kosinski (Road Rules: X-treme)
12 seasons, 3 wins

Darrell Taylor (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)
11 seasons, 4 wins

Two players quit, and another two disqualified during ‘All Stars 3’

According to the spoiler, the Challengers aren’t competing in pairs like last season. Instead, the players seemingly compete individually. The top three females and males who finish the mission are safe and determine the competitor who will face the last-place finisher in elimination. 

Cynthia eliminated by Tina

Tyler eliminated by Syrus

Laterrian eliminated by Mark

Syrus eliminated by MJ

Kendal eliminated by Beth

Darrell eliminated by Jordan

Yes eliminated by Wes

Jordan eliminated by Mark

It’s unclear who sent them home, but Sylvia, MJ, Roni, Veronica, and Derrick were eliminated before the finals.

Melinda reportedly quit during the elimination round when about to face Tina due to an injury she sustained in the All Stars 2 final. Additionally, Beth chose to leave on her own accord before facing off against Jonna in an elimination round. Tina was later disqualified following an injury, and Jemmye left the competition early at some point due to a family emergency.

Jonna and Wes won ‘All Stars 3’

Nia placed fourth, followed by KellyAnne, and runner-up Kailah. Last season’s winner, Jonna, took home the title again.


‘The Challenge’: Janelle Casanave Says She Might Not Return Due to Mishandlings During Final

For the men, Mark placed fourth, Nehemiah; third, Brad clocked second, and Wes won. The Challenge: All Stars Season 1 and 2 are streaming on Paramount+.