‘The Challenge: All Stars’: Are KellyAnne Judd and Nehemiah Clark Dating?

The Challenge stars KellyAnne Judd and Nehemiah Clark returned for the OG spinoff, All-Stars, following an extended break from the competition. After the show, the two have continued hanging out, and many fans have noticed a spark between the MTV fan-favorites. Are they dating?

TV personality KellyAnne Judd attends the 3rd Annual Reality TV Awards
TV personality KellyAnne Judd attends the 3rd Annual Reality TV Awards | David Livingston

KellyAnne Judd and Nehemiah Clark both returned for ‘The Challenge: All Stars’

In 2005, California native Nehemiah Clark made his reality television debut on The Real World: Austin, followed by KellyAnnne Judd, who starred in the Sydney installment two years later.

Both played their best game during their sophomore season, with Nehemiah winning The Gauntlet III (2008), and she came up short in The Ruins’ finals, earning a little over $13,000.

RELATED: ‘The Challenge’ Star Trishelle Cannatella Says ‘All Stars’ Spinoff Has More Drama Than Regular Seasons

However, neither have placed well enough in the next two seasons they competed in to leave with any prize money. Nehemiah hasn’t returned since 2011’s Rivals, and viewers last saw KellyAnne in 2016 during Rivals III.

The old school competitors decided to come back for the OG spinoff, All-Stars.

Fans speculate KellyAnne and Nehemiah started dating after the show

Although the two began their MTV career around the same time, they have never competed together until All-Stars.

During the premiere episode, Nehemiah played a crucial role in helping his team win the daily mission, while KellyAnne was the captain of the losing team.

However, she avoided elimination because it went to the guys. Following the episode’s debut, Nehemiah and KellyAnne have frequently updated their Instagram Stories with videos of each other.

RELATED: ‘The Challenge: All Stars’: Which Competitor Has the Most Wins?

In one video, she said he was staying at her place and joked that he would “leave” her. Another clip pictured Nehemiah sitting between KellyAnne’s legs while she encouraged him to choose between two drinks.

The two then went out for lunch together the following day. One viewer created a Twitter thread including pictures of The Challenge stars, noting it seemed they had “sexual tension” between them.

A fan account on Instagram also posted the videos, and several followers noted they were “here” for the potential couple. Nehemiah later commented on the post and explained he and KellyAnne have remained “best friends” for several years. She has yet to respond.

KellyAnne previously dated Wes Bergmann

During The Real World: Sydney, KellyAnne began dating roommate and future Challenger Cohutta Grindstaff, but they ended their relationship before competing on the spinoff.

Following her rookie season, she began dating Nehemiah’s former roommate from Austin, Wes Bergmann, and they both competed on The Ruins (2009). However, during the reunion special, the two revealed they broke up but planned on working things out.

RELATED: ‘The Challenge’: Wes Bergmann on Why He Didn’t Return for ‘All Stars’

Ultimately, the couple chose to officially part in 2010. Nehemiah and Wes are very good friends and have remained close throughout the years. He officiated Wes’s wedding, and the two recently worked on a project together before he returned for All-Stars.

If the two are dating, it’s unclear if Nehemiah broke “guy code” but Wes likely doesn’t care as he’s happily married. Additionally, he and his wife are doing recaps of the spinoff on Patreon, and he joked about how she would “interpret seeing my ex-GF grace the screen.” The Challenge: All-Stars airs on Paramount+.