Skip to main content

‘The Challenge’ Season 37 Reunion: Amanda Garcia Promises to Spill Tea About Michele Fitzgerald

MTV's 'The Challenge' Season 37 cast members Amanda Garcia and Michele Fitzgerald have beef -- and it could have something to do with Fessy Shafaat, Amanda's current boyfriend. Now, Amanda promises to air Michele's dirty laundry during 'The Challenge' Season 37 reunion. Here's what's going on.
Michele Fitzgerald from MTV's 'The Challenge' Season 37 on 'Survivor.' Amanda Garcia and Michele Fitzgerald have a rivalry from 'The Challenge'
Michele Fitzgerald on ‘Survivor’ | Timothy Kuratek/CBS via Getty Images

MTV’s The Challenge Season 37 is heating up with drama. The Challenge Season 37 cast members Amanda Garcia and Fessy Shafaat appear to have made their relationship Instagram official. But prior to their romantic getaway, rumors suggested Fessy got close with Michele Fitzgerald. More recently, Amanda took to Instagram Live to spill even more tea about Michele — and she promised more is coming at the show’s reunion.

Amanda Garcia and Fessy Shafaat from MTV’s ‘The Challenge’ Season 37 are dating

MTV’s The Challenge Season 37 cast members often hook up on the show, and that’s exactly how Amanda and Fessy’s relationship started. The two met on Spies, Lies, and Allies and started flirting from the beginning, though they didn’t make their relationship official on the show. Instead, Amanda and Fessy kept their romance extremely casual. And it seems Fessy had a number of hookups and potential relationships stemming from the season.

Now, Fessy made his relationship with Amanda Instagram official. On Sept. 10, he added a series of photos of himself and Amanda with their arms around each other. And the last photo in the set shows Fessy holding Amanda romantically in his arms.

“It’s something about you but I really can’t explain it,” he captioned the set of photos.

Amanda Garcia has beef with Michele Fitzgerald — and she promises to air it

Now, the drama is heating up between The Challenge Season 37 cast members Amanda and Michele. While the two seemed friendly and appeared on each other’s Instagram Lives, Amanda’s now spilling the tea. According to Amanda, Michele and Fessy had a relationship or hookup of some kind, and Michele wasn’t honest with Amanda regarding what occurred. Michele allegedly told Amanda she and Fessy only kissed. But Amanda seems to think more occurred between the rookie and the veteran player.

It looks like fans might hear more about this rivalry during MTV’s The Challenge Season 377 reunion, too. According to Amanda, she’s airing all of Michele’s dirty laundry during the reunion episode. This includes Michele’s alleged bad-mouthing about fellow contestants Tori Deal and Ashley Mitchell.

“Amanda said … she’s gonna tell everyone what Michele has been saying about them to her on camera at the reunion so everyone can know how [Michele] really feels,” a Reddit user noted. “Michele tries to pretend to be friends with everyone for future seasons but bashes them to her and Ashley.”

‘The Challenge’ Season 37 reunion: When will it air?

Fessy Shafaat from MTV's 'The Challenge' Season 37 cast lounging in the 'Big Brother' house. Fessy is dating Amanda Garcia
Fessy Shafaat | Sonja Flemming/CBS via Getty Images

‘The Challenge’ Season 37 Spoilers: A Disqualification Plus Another 1-on-1 Elimination Are Coming in Episode 6

The Challenge Season 36 had a reunion that involved plenty of questions for Fessy and Tori. Now, the questions will likely come back to Fessy and Michele. So, when will MTV’s The Challenge Season 37 reunion air? According to Parade, we’ll likely see the finale around Dec. 15, 2021. The reunion special will likely air in two parts in the following weeks at the end of the year.

We look forward to hearing about what’s to come in The Challenge Season 37 reunion and if Amanda really will call out Michele as she says she will. By December, there could be further developments regarding her relationship with Fessy, too. This could certainly impact what happens at the reunion special.

The Challenge Season 37 air date is Wednesdays at 8 p.m. EST on MTV.

Check out Showbiz Cheat Sheet on Facebook!