Fans Urge Hailey Bieber to Stay Silent on Father’s Day After Justin’s Controversial Mother’s Day Post
Rumors have been circulating about Justin Bieber and Hailey Bieber, with fans speculating about possible tension behind the scenes of their seemingly picture-perfect marriage. From cryptic social media posts to noticeably solo public appearances, the internet has been buzzing with theories about trouble in paradise. While Hailey addressed the speculation directly, subtle signs continue to fuel the fire, leaving followers wondering if the glossy Instagram snapshots are hiding something more complicated beneath the surface. More recently, fans want Hailey to say nothing on Father’s Day after Justin’s controversial Mother’s Day comment. Here’s why.
Justin Bieber posted that ‘Mother’s Day sucks’ on his Instagram Stories
Justin and Hailey Bieber have always kept fans guessing. Their whirlwind 2018 engagement caused a stir amongst fans, as did their ultra-private courthouse wedding and glamorous South Carolina celebration. What started as a teenage friendship quickly evolved into one of Hollywood’s most talked-about romances. However, in recent months, cracks have reportedly started to show in their fairytale relationship. Between Justin’s cryptic Instagram rants and Hailey’s subtle social media tweaks, fans are speculating that all may not be well behind closed doors.
In May 2025, Justin Bieber sparked controversy with a cryptic and quickly deleted Instagram story that read, “Love u moms but Mother’s Day sucks a**.” The post, shared on his wife Hailey Bieber’s first Mother’s Day following the birth of their son, Jack, drew widespread backlash from fans and followers. Many interpreted the message as disrespectful to Hailey, especially given the occasion. The situation intensified when Justin later shared a screenshot of the song “Resentment” by PartyNextDoor, tagging Hailey and adding crying and shrugging emojis. This series of posts led to increased speculation about the state of their relationship and concerns over Bieber’s emotional well-being.
Hailey Bieber fans are calling for her to ignore her husband on Father’s Day
As Justin Bieber continues to stir the pot via Instagram, Hailey Bieber has performed extensive damage control. She’s assured her followers that she and Justin are better than ever. Despite her insistence that no one should have concerns regarding her marriage, fans want her to forget about wishing her husband a happy Father’s Day after the offensive Mother’s Day post he added to his Instagram Stories.
“Hailey, don’t you dare post anything for Father’s Day,” a fan on Reddit commented after seeing Justin’s Mother’s Day post.
“For him so be so insensitive when I believe this is Hailey’s first Mother’s Day (sorry, I don’t follow much) is wild,” another fan wrote.
If Hailey publicly wishes Justin well this Father’s Day, she might do it on her Instagram Stories so as not to accrue a hefty comment section from outsiders. However, she might also choose to purposely prove her haters wrong by wishing her husband a great day.
Hailey Bieber slammed the divorce rumors in a recent interview
Hailey Bieber knows about the divorce rumors plaguing her and Justin Bieber. In May 2025, she explained to Vogue how she has a “real life” with a “beautiful family,” a son she loves, and friends. Hailey also explained how therapy helped her reach a place of acceptance and peace.
“Being postpartum is the most sensitive time I’ve ever gone through in my life, and learning a new version of myself is very difficult,” she said. “And to be doing that all the while going on the internet every day and people being like, They’re getting divorced and They’re this and They’re not happy: It is such a mindf***. I cannot even begin to explain it. It’s a crazy life to live.”
Despite Hailey’s reassurance that all’s well with her and Justin, fans will still psychoanalyze his Instagram posts for signs of distress. And they won’t forgive that Mother’s Day post just yet.
For more news and exclusive interviews, follow Showbiz Cheat Sheet’s Instagram.
