‘Top Gun: Maverick’: A Legal Expert Explains How Paramount Will Defend Itself in Copyright Lawsuit
Tom Cruise has never had a movie like Top Gun: Maverick. Financially, it already is or is pacing to be different from every other Cruise movie. Fans love the film, and the reviews have been positive. As Maverick soars, though, a copyright lawsuit against Paramount Pictures threatens to ground it.
Lawsuit claims Paramount broke copyright laws with ‘Top Gun: Maverick’
Maverick gave Cruise his best opening weekend and provided Paramount with a box office winner, but bad news could loom.
A lawsuit filed in California claims Paramount and the filmmakers violated copyright laws. Ehud Yonay’s 1983 magazine article, Top Guns, helped inspire the original movie. His heirs, Shosh and Yuval Yonay, claim they informed Paramount they would reclaim the copyright in January 2020, CNBC reports.
They claim Paramount and the filmmakers — Cruise, Jerry Bruckheimer, and Christopher McQuarrie are three of 10 producers listed in the credits, per IMDb — did not hold the rights when Maverick finished filming. The Yonays claim the movie didn’t finish filming until 2021, after the rights reverted.
If and when the case goes to court, Paramount has several arguments in its defense, according to ABC legal expert Dan Abrams.
Legal expert Dan Abrams explains how Paramount could defend itself in the lawsuit
The lawsuit against Top Gun: Maverick and Paramount is a long way to trial, and there’s a chance the suit could settle out of court. Yet Paramount has several strong arguments in its favor, as Abrams noted on Good Morning America.
“There are a lot of defenses here. First of all, they’re saying the first movie wasn’t actually even a derivative of the actual article, we think they’re going to argue. Furthermore, we think they’re going to say, ‘Even if it was, the second movie certainly wasn’t a derivative of that original article.’ Remember, facts aren’t copyrightable.
“And the other thing they’re likely going to argue is that they finished [or] substantially completed the movie within the 35-year period. Remember, there have been a lot of delays in this film, and they’re going to say they substantially completed the film before the rights reverted back.”ABC legal expert Dan Abrams
Maverick finished filming in 2019, according to IMDb. Even with reshoots, most of what appears on screen could have been shot while Paramount had the rights.
Paramount has the upper hand in the ‘Top Gun: Maverick’ lawsuit, according to Abrams
Abrams noted during his GMA appearance that property rights are a huge concern in Hollywood right now. The same lawyer representing the Yonays also represents several comic book heirs suing Disney over its Marvel rights, as CNBC reports.
If the lawsuit against Paramount over Top Gun: Maverick goes to court, Abrams indicated Paramount could win because it has so many lines of defense.
“It’s always going to be tough when you’re the plaintiff in a case like this. [Paramount] has some serious legal firepower behind them,” Abrams said. “It’s not a frivolous argument, but it’s also not going to be an easy argument to win, in particular because Paramount has so many different arguments they can make, and if they win any one of them, they win the case. They can say, ‘OK, you don’t accept that argument, you don’t accept that argument, but if you accept the third one, we still win.’”
How much ‘Maverick’ cost to make and how much it’s earned so far
The lawsuit against Paramount aims to halt distribution of Maverick, stop any further sequels, and seeks monetary compensation, CNBC reports.
If the plaintiffs win in court and the judge awards the Yonays a percentage of the profits, it could be a financial windfall.
Eleven days after opening in theaters, Maverick earned more than $557.2 million worldwide, according to Box Office Mojo. It’s already a huge money-maker for Paramount, which spent an estimated $170 million to make the movie, per IMDb.
Time will tell what happens to the lawsuit — tossed, settled, or heard in court — but if it goes in front of a judge, Paramount has several lines of defense.
For more on the entertainment world and exclusive interviews, subscribe to Showbiz Cheat Sheet’s YouTube channel.